He went into the house and found a threesome of his acting friends getting busy. It was Taylor Lautner, Sasha Inman, and Nolan Gould. While he’d guessed that Nolan secretly had a thing for Sasha, he would’ve bet big money she never realized it.
While she kissed Taylor, Nolan was giving Sasha head.
“Oh fuck, Taylor, I can’t wait. I’ve wanted this for so long,” she moaned. “Please, fuck me. Claim me.”
Nolan’s head snapped up with a desperate look in his eyes.
“Wait … I … uh,” he stuttered, then exclaimed, “Let me get you wet first!”
David blinked as Nolan went down on Taylor. He would never unsee that, so he went to look in the downstairs guest room for Crystal.
The door was partially open, so he assumed it was empty. When he opened it, he found Crystal lying on her stomach on the bed as a porn actor he recognized took her from behind. His stage name was Little Timmy because his body looked like he was a twelve-year-old boy with a man-sized cock attached to it. He mostly did MILF scenes with older women.
Crystal heard him come in and glanced back. She wore a determined look that dared him to say anything. David
mouthed the word ‘sorry’ as he backed out of the room.
Crystal’s face fell when she saw her bluff hadn’t worked.
David closed the door and took a deep breath in the hall.
He quickly checked himself and found that he wasn’t really all that upset. Crystal had told him what she intended to do and followed through on it. It wasn’t like he couldn’t have stopped it if he’d wanted to. He was the one who said he wanted casual. How could he be mad if she was the first to find someone else to spend time with?
That was something else that changed with age. The old David’s Alpha Male would have been shouting ‘Mine!’ with any girl he’d been with. While that instinct was still there, it was reserved for people like Brook. Whenever he heard she was dating someone, he thought of tracking the offending male down and ending him. But that thought wasn’t there for Crystal, which told him a lot.
He might have called an Uber and gone home if he wasn’t a big brother. Instead, he continued looking for Phil to ensure he was okay.
He finally found him in the main bedroom with Bethany, the 21 Naturals photographer, Roc, Emily, and Wren. He was surprised they were all clothed and looked like they were just chatting and getting to know each other.
Roc was sitting on the bed, leaning against the headboard, with Bethany sitting between his legs. The other three were sitting crossed-legged.
“I figured you’d be in the middle of all that,” Phil said when David walked in.
“I’m not really in the mood,” David admitted.
“I take it that Crystal is,” Emily said.
“Actually, she is,” David said.
“I’m sorry. Are you okay?” Wren asked.
“Me, too,” Emily said. “That was sort of bitchy to say.”
He could hear in her voice that Emily meant what she’d just said. He’d felt more than once that she had a crush on
him. The same could be said about Wren, but she was dating Big Cat.
“Why aren’t you with your boyfriend?” David asked Wren.
“And get passed around like a party favor? No thanks,”
she said to David’s surprise.
“Oh, I thought you were fine with that,” David said since he’d heard of her sleeping with multiple guys at different outings.
Wren got a sad look on her face.
“I told you about the first guy I dated in high school. He was two years older, which is a lot in high school. He was also my first, so I had minimal experience with having a boyfriend. Plus, guys didn’t look my way until the summer before my sophomore year, and these grew in,” Wren said as she hefted her breasts.
David could only imagine because Wren was sporting a
‘D’ cup, and they must have looked huge on her skinny sophomore body. He bet every senior … correction, every guy at her school took notice and worked to get into her pants.
“I was suddenly getting a lot of attention, but when my ex took notice, I was lost. He was the guy every girl wanted. I felt special, and my friends all were jealous that I’d bagged the big man on campus. That was why I was willing to do stuff like let him finger me in school. I thought I had to, to keep him.
“He took great joy in displaying me for his friends,”
Wren said, getting a faraway look.
“What happened?” Phil asked.
“It was graduation, and there was a party. I’d had a few too many, so I didn’t notice when he started fingering me that all his buddies had gathered around to watch. He pulled his cock out and told me to suck it, so I did. Then he pulled it out and fucked me. When he was done, he rolled off, and one of his friends took his place.
“Before the night was done, I’d fucked seven guys,”
Wren said.
“Jesus,” Roc said.
“I should have broken up with him, but I didn’t. I thought he loved me, and I loved him enough to do whatever he asked. All summer long, before he left for college, he would fuck me, and then one or more of his buddies would do me.
“I found that if I got started, my mind would turn off, and I let them have me. The part that scares me is that I liked it,” Wren grudgingly admitted.
“So, in the hotel with Lars and the rest?” David asked.
“I fell back into my old ways,” Wren said.
“If you told me, I would have stopped them,” David said.
“Honestly, I wanted it. But after that, I told myself I was done with being used. That was why I dated Big Cat. He’s a sweet guy, but Chuy and the others told him they wanted to party with me again. Big Cat said they would tonight, so I broke up with him.”
David’s phone buzzed to indicate a message had come in. He saw it was time to get everyone to go back to campus.
“We’ve got to go,” David said as he sent out a group text to wrap everything up and meet at the bus.
◊◊◊
It took a half hour, but he finally tracked down all the recruits. Not all the football players were accounted for, but they weren’t his responsibility. They could figure out their own way back to campus.
He saw Crystal taking a nose count of her sorority sisters, and she looked frustrated.
“Missing someone?” David asked.
“Taylor.”
David held up a finger.
“I might know where she is.”
He called Bec.
“Did you leave?” Bec asked when she answered.
“I’m loading everyone up, and I wanted to say goodbye.
But first, I need your help. We’re missing a sorority girl.”
“Taylor?” she asked.
“That’s the one.”
“She’s in the shower with Zak. I’ll send her right out.”
“Thanks.”
“And David …”
“Yes?”
“Next time, I won’t just tease you,” Bec said and hung up.
Mr. Happy must have been eavesdropping because he instantly got hard.
“She’ll be out in a minute,” David said.
“Thanks,” Crystal said and then blurted out, “About earlier.”
David pulled her in for a hug and kissed the top of her head.
“We’re all good,” he said, letting her off the hook.
He got onto the lead bus and told the driver they could leave.
◊◊◊
When David got back to his dorm, he found Alex and Chloe sitting on the couch, watching a movie. Their hair was wet, so he assumed they’d taken advantage of him not being home.