“You knew then,” said Beauvoir.
“I wondered. I thought it was something you should consider.”
“Then why didn’t you tell me during our call?” he asked. “Why that vague hint?”
“It’s against company policy to admit our revolvers are used for something that cruel. I could be fired. But I needed you to know. I realize it wasn’t the most obvious of hints, but it was the best I could do. I was hoping you’d know that scene from the film.”
“I didn’t, but a colleague saw it last night and put it together. Why did you ask about the special case for the revolver?”
“From what I gather, a ritual is often created. A special case is made. It becomes a sort of ceremony.”
He could hear the disgust in her voice.
“I could be wrong,” she said.
“But you don’t think you are, do you?”
Beauvoir was still lost, but one answer had appeared on the very edges of his mind. An outlier. A terrible monster of an idea. Lurking, pacing, just beyond his reason.
And with the next thing Madame Coldbrook said, it raced across the border, clawing its way to the very front of his mind.
“Only a revolver can be used. The barrel has to spin for the game to work. Was he killed playing it, do you think?”
The game.
The blood raced from Beauvoir’s extremities so quickly he almost dropped the phone.
The game.
They now knew why Leduc had a revolver.
In the single light of the kitchen, Jean-Guy looked at his father-in-law.
Gamache was staring at the floor and shaking his head slightly.
“You can’t have known, patron. It must’ve been going on for years.”
Jean-Guy immediately regretted that last statement, as Gamache winced.
Then he looked up and met Jean-Guy’s gaze.
“Can you imagine?” he said quietly. “Their terror? And no one did anything to stop it. I did nothing to stop it.”
“You didn’t know.”
“I could have fired him. I should’ve fired him. I kept him on to keep an eye on him while I gathered more information on his corruption. I was looking in that direction and completely missed the worst thing Leduc was doing.”
“No one saw it.”
“Oh, someone saw it,” said Gamache, his rage bursting out.
He managed to rein it in, but it roiled just below his skin. Turning it red.
“You’re right,” said Jean-Guy. “Someone knew what was happening. They put a gun to Leduc’s head and pulled the trigger.”
He saw a look on the older man’s face. A primitive, primal, savage moment. Of satisfaction. And then it was gone.
“Was that the motive?”
“Oui,” said Gamache. “I think so.”
Madame Coldbrook had asked if Leduc had died playing the game. He hadn’t. Never did. But still, it killed him. He’d been murdered. Executed. Not in the game, but because of it.
“Whoever killed him tried to implicate you,” Beauvoir said. “By placing your fingerprints on the revolver. Making it look like you’d murdered Leduc. It was Charpentier, wasn’t it?”
Gamache looked at the kitchen clock. Three thirty in the morning.
“We need to get some sleep,” he said. “We have a big day ahead of us.”
But sleep eluded Jean-Guy. He lay staring at the ceiling. Gamache had asked if he could imagine. He lay there and tried to imagine what it was like for those cadets, who were not just cadets. They were someone’s sons and daughters. Someone’s children.
And he imagined his own child, in that situation. With no one doing anything to stop it. To help them. And Jean-Guy began to understand that look of savagery on his father-in-law’s face.
But he also, then, remembered something else. The subtle movement of Gamache’s foot as he shoved something between the chair and the wall.
Unable to sleep, Jean-Guy got up and tiptoed down the stairs, into the kitchen. Turning on the lamp, he found the box and picked it up. And held it, staring at the lid. There were fingerprints on it. One set, and one set only, he knew.
Gamache’s.
He stared at the shoe box. It wasn’t one of the ones from the historical society. He knew that. This one was private and personal.
And in it sat the answer to so many questions.
Then he slowly bent down and replaced it.
Turning around, he almost fainted. There in the doorway stood Gamache.
“Did no one tell you, Jean-Guy, if you’re going to do a clandestine search, never turn the light on?”
“I missed that class.”
Gamache smiled and, walking forward, he stopped in front of Jean-Guy and looked from the man to the box on the floor, then back to the man.
“Merci.”
“I shouldn’t have even considered looking,” said Jean-Guy. “I’m sorry.”
“Non, not at all. It’s human to be curious. It was superhuman to put it back down. Thank you for respecting my privacy.”
Then Armand Gamache walked past Jean-Guy, picked up the old box, and handed it to his son-in-law.
Without a word, he returned upstairs, while Jean-Guy returned to the armchair and opened the box.
CHAPTER 39
Armand Gamache looked at the cadets, one at a time.
First Nathaniel, then Huifen, then Jacques, and finally his eyes rested on Amelia.
“I know,” he said quietly.
Jacques turned his head slightly, eyes narrowing. “Know what?”
“I know what happened in Leduc’s rooms.”
There was silence then. The cadets looked at each other, and then all, naturally, turned to Huifen.
“What?” she asked. There was defiance in her voice.
Jean-Guy Beauvoir was sitting a few benches back. He and Armand had brought the young people up to the chapel first thing in the morning. They needed to speak to them, and they needed someplace private. And neutral. And peaceful.
“I’ve long known that Serge Leduc was corrupt,” said Gamache. “I came out of retirement to clean up the academy. And not just of corruption. It was clear by the quality of new agents entering the Sûreté that something was very wrong at the school. They were competent in the techniques, but they were also cruel. Not all, of course, but enough. More than enough. There was something wrong either with the recruitment process, or with the training. Or both.”
As he spoke, Commander Gamache watched them. And they watched him.
If Gamache and Beauvoir thought the four would break down and tell them everything, they were wrong. The conspiracy of silence was so ingrained as to be almost unbreakable.
“The first thing I did was fire most of your professors, and I brought in my own. Officers with real-life experience of investigations. Men and women with integrity. But who also know that with power comes temptation. Those are the real threats to Sûreté agents. The self-inflicted wounds.”
Jean-Guy could hear their breathing now. At least one, perhaps more, of the cadets was on the verge of hyperventilating.
And still they were still. And silent.
“But I kept Serge Leduc, the Duke, on.”
“Why?” asked Nathaniel.
Looking at the pale young man, Gamache tried to catch his own breath. He looked down at his hands, clasped together. Holding on tight.
Serge Leduc might have done great damage. But so had he.
If he expected the students to tell him the truth, he had to be willing to do the same.