“Forty-nine-five, loaded.”
“Like hell! I don’t even come close to making that in a year.”
“Neither did I until recently.”
“Public defenders don’t make the big bucks, I’ve heard.”
“You heard right.”
The men fell silent. Frank knew he was breaking more rules than they probably had written down and Jack knew that too.
Finally Jack looked at him. “Look, Lieutenant, I’m assuming you didn’t just come out here to check my taste in automobiles. Is there something you want?”
“Gorelick’s got a winning case against your guy.”
“Maybe. Maybe not. I’m not throwing in the towel if that’s what you’re thinking.”
“You pleading him not guilty?”
“No, I’m gonna drive him down to the Greensville Correctional Center and inject the shit into him myself. Next question.”
Frank smiled. “Okay, I deserved that. I think you and I need to talk. Some things about this case don’t add up. Maybe it helps or hurts your guy, I don’t know. You willing to listen?”
“Okay, but don’t think this flow of information is going to be a two-way street.”
“I know a place where you can actually cut the meatloaf with a butter knife and the coffee’s passable.”
“Is it an out-of-the-way place? I don’t think you’d look good in a deputy’s uniform.”
Frank looked over at him, grinning. “Next question.”
Jack managed a smile and then drove home to change.
Jack ordered another cup of coffee while Frank played with his first. The meatloaf had been terrific and the place was so isolated, Jack wasn’t even sure where they were. Rural, southern Maryland he thought. He looked around at the few occupants of the rustic dining room. No one was paying them any undue attention. He turned back to his companion.
Frank looked at him in an amused fashion. “I understand you and Kate Whitney had a thing going a while back.”
“Did she tell you that?”
“Hell no. She came down to the station a few minutes after you left today. Her father wouldn’t see her. I talked with her for a while. Told her I was sorry about how things had gone down.”
Frank’s eyes glistened for a moment and then he continued. “I shouldn’t have done what I did, Jack. Using her to get to her old man. Nobody deserves that.”
“It worked. Some people would say don’t argue with success.”
“Right. Well anyway the subject got around to you. I’m not so old yet that I can’t see a gleam in a woman’s eyes.”
The waitress brought Jack’s coffee. He sipped it. Both men looked out the window where the snow had finally stopped and the whole earth seemed to be covered with a soft, white blanket.
“Look, Jack, I know the case against Luther is just about all circumstantial. But that’s sent plenty of people to jail.”
“I’m not arguing with that.”
“The truth is, Jack, there’s an awful lot of shit that doesn’t make any sense.”
Jack put down his coffee and leaned forward.
“I’m listening.”
Frank looked around the room and then back at Jack. “I know I’m taking a chance doing this, but I didn’t become a cop to send people to jail for crimes they didn’t commit. Plenty enough guilty people out there.”
“So what doesn’t add up?”
“You’ll see some of it for yourself in the reports you’ll get in your discovery, but the fact is I’m convinced Luther Whitney burgled that house and I’m also convinced that he didn’t kill Christine Sullivan. But—”
“But you think he saw who did.”
Frank sat back in his chair and stared wide-eyed at Jack. “How long have you thought that?”
“Not long. Any ideas on the matter?”
“I’m thinking your guy almost got caught with his hand in the cookie jar and then had to actually hide in that cookie jar.”
Jack looked puzzled. Frank took a few minutes to explain about the vault, the incongruity of the physical evidence and his own questions.
“So Luther’s in the vault all this time watching whoever gets it on with Mrs. Sullivan. Then something happens and she gets popped. Then Luther watches whoever wipe away all traces.”
“That’s how I got it figured, Jack.”
“So he doesn’t go to the cops because he can’t without incriminating himself.”
“That explains a lot.”
“Except who did it.”
“The only obvious suspect is the husband, and I don’t believe it was him.”
Jack thought back to Walter Sullivan. “Agreed. So who’s not so obvious?”
“Whoever she was meeting that night.”
“From what you’ve told me about the deceased’s sex life, that narrows it down to a couple million.”
“I didn’t say it would be easy.”
“Well, my hunch is it’s not some ordinary Joe.”
“Why’s that?”
Jack took a swallow of coffee and looked at his slice of apple pie. “Look, Lieutenant—”
“Make it Seth.”
“Okay, Seth, I’m walking a fine line here. I hear where you’re coming from and I appreciate the info. But...”
“But you’re not absolutely sure you can trust me, and in any event, you don’t want to say anything that might prejudice your client?”
“Something like that.”
“Fair enough.”
They paid the bill and left. Driving back the snow started again with such velocity that the wipers were having a hard time keeping up.
Jack looked over at Frank, who stared straight ahead, lost in thought or maybe just waiting for Jack to start talking.
“Okay. I’ll take the chance, I don’t have a helluva lot to lose, do I?”
Frank continued to stare straight ahead. “Not that I can see.”
“Let’s assume for the moment that Luther was in the house and saw the woman murdered.”
Frank looked over at Jack; there was relief in the detective’s features.
“Okay.”
“You’ve got to know Luther, know how he thinks, to understand how he would react to something like that. He’s about as unshakable a person as I’ve ever met. And I know his record doesn’t indicate it, but he’s about as trustworthy and dependable as you can get. If I had kids and needed to leave them with someone I’d leave them with Luther because I know absolutely nothing bad would happen to them on his watch. He’s incredibly capable. Luther sees everything. He’s a control freak.”
“Everything except his daughter leading him into a trap.”
“Right, except for that. He wouldn’t have seen that coming. Not in a million years.”
“But I know the kind of guy you’re talking about, Jack. Some of the guys I’ve busted, except for the little habit of taking other people’s property, they’re some of the most honorable people I’ve ever met.”
“And if Luther saw this woman killed, I’m telling you he would’ve found some way to deliver the guy to the cops. He wouldn’t have let it go. He just wouldn’t!” Jack stared grimly out the window.
“Except?”
Jack looked over at him. “Except for a helluva good reason. Like maybe he knew the person or knew of him.”
“You mean the kind of person people would have a hard time believing could do something like that so Luther figures why even bother?”
“There’s more to it than that, Seth.” Jack turned the corner and pulled up next to the YMCA. “I’ve never seen Luther scared before this all happened. And he’s scared now. Terrified in fact. He’s resigned himself to take the rap for the whole thing and I don’t know why. I mean he left the country for godsakes.”
“And came back.”
“Right, which I still cannot figure out. You have the date by the way?”