academic circles in the United States, do not allow an outside observer to feel any great
optimism for the future either of the Milner Group or of the great institutions which it has
influenced. It would seem that the great idealistic adventure which began with Toynbee
and Milner in 1875 had slowly ground its way to a finish of bitterness and ashes.
Appendix—A Tentative Roster of the Milner Group
The following lists are tentative in the sense that they are incomplete and erroneous.
The errors are more likely in the attribution of persons to one circle of the Group rather
than another, and are less likely in the attribution to the Group of persons who are not
members at all. For the names given I have sufficient evidence to convince me that they
are members of the Croup, although I would not in many cases feel competent to insist
that the persons concerned knew that they were members of a secret group. The evidence
on which this list is based is derived from documentary evidence, from private
information, and from circumstantial evidence.
Persons are listed in each group on the basis of general impression rather than exact
demarcation, because the distinction between the two is rather vague and varies from
time to time. For example, I know for a fact that Sir Alfred Zimmern and Lord Cecil of
Chelwood attended meetings of the inner circle in the period before 1920, but I have
attributed them to the outer circle because this appears to be the more accurate
designation for the long period since 1920.
Within each list I have placed the names of the various individuals in order of
chronology and of importance. In some cases where I suspected a person of being a
member without having any very convincing evidence, I have enclosed the name in
brackets.
A. The Society of the Elect
Cecil John Rhodes
Nathan Rothschild, Baron Rothschild
Sir Harry Johnston
William T. Stead
Reginald Brett, Viscount Esher
Alfred Milner, Viscount Milner
B. F. Hawksley
Thomas Brassey, Lord Brassey
Edmund Garrett
[Sir Edward Cook]
Alfred Beit
Sir Abe Bailey
Albert Grey, Earl Grey
Archibald Primrose, Earl of Rosebery
Arthur James Balfour
Sir George R. Parkin
Philip Lyttelton Gell
Sir Henry Birchenough
Sir Reginald Sothern Holland
Arthur Lionel Smith
Herbert A. L. Fisher
William Waldegrave Palmer, Earl of Selborne
[Sir Alfred Lyttelton]
Sir Patrick Duncan
Robert Henry Brand, Baron Brand
Philip Kerr, Marquess of Lothian
Lionel Curtis
Geoffrey Dawson
Edward Grigg, Baron Altrincham
Jan C. Smuts
Leopold Amery
Waldorf Astor, Viscount Astor
Nancy Astor, Lady Astor
B. The Association of Helpers
1. The Inner Circle
Sir Patrick Duncan
Robert Henry Brand, Baron Brand
Philip Kerr, Marquess of Lothian
Lionel Curtis
William L. Hichens
Geoffrey Dawson
Edward Grigg, Baron Altrincham
Herbert A. L. Fisher
Leopold Amery
Richard Feetham
Hugh A. Wyndham
Sir Dougal Malcolm
Basil Williams
Basil Kellett Long
Sir Abe Bailey
Jan C. Smuts
Sir William Marris
James S. Meston
Baron Meston
Malcolm Hailey
Baron Hailey
Flora Shaw
Lady Lugard
Sir Reginald Coupland
Waldorf Astor, Viscount Astor
Nancy Astor, Lady Astor
Maurice Hankey, Baron Hankey
Arnold J. Toynbee
Laurence F. Rushbrook Williams
Henry Vincent Hodson
Vincent Todd Harlow
2. The Outer Circle
John Buchan, Baron Tweedsmuir
Sir Fabian Ware
Sir Alfred Zimmern
Gilbert Murray
Robert Cecil, Viscount Cecil of Chelwood
Sir James W. Headlam-Morley
Frederick J. N. Thesiger, Viscount Chelmsford
Sir Valentine Chirol
Edward F. L. Wood, Earl of Halifax
Sir [James] Arthur Salter
Sir Arthur H. D. R. Steel-Maitland
William G. A. Ormsby-Gore, Baron Harlech
Dame Edith Lyttelton, Mrs. Alfred Lyttelton
Frederick Lugard, Baron Lugard
Sir [Leander] Starr Jameson
Henry W. C. Davis
John A. Simon, Viscount Simon
Samuel J. G. Hoare, Viscount Templewood
Maurice P. A. Hankey, Baron Hankey
Wilson Harris
[Francis Clarke]
William G. S. Adams
[William K. Hancock]
Ernest L. Woodward
Sir Harold Butler
Kenneth N. Bell
Sir Donald B. Somervell
Sir Maurice L. Gwyer
Charles R. S. Harris
Sir Edward R. Peacock
Sir Cyril J. Radcliffe
John W. Wheeler-Bennett
Robert J. Stopford
Robert M. Barrington-Ward
[Kenneth C. Wheare]
Edward H. Carr
Malcolm MacDonald
Godfrey Elton, Baron Elton
Sir Neill Malcolm
Freeman Freeman-Thomas, Viscount Willingdon
Isaiah Berlin
Roger M. Makins
Sir Arthur Willert
Ivison S. Macadam
3. Members in other countries
a. Canada
Arthur J. Glazebrook
Sir George Parkin
Vincent Massey
George P. de T. Glazebrook
Percy Corbett [Sir Joseph Flavelle]
b. United States
George Louis Beer
Frank Aydelotte
Jerome Greene
[Clarence Steit]
c. South Africa
Jan C. Smuts
Sir Patrick Duncan
Sir Abe Bailey
Basil K. Long
Richard Feetham
[Sir James Rose-Innes]
d. Australia
Sir Thomas Bavin
Sir Frederic Eggleston
[Dudley D. Braham]
e. New Zealand
James Allen
William Downie Stewart
Arthur R. Atkinson
f. Germany
Helmuth James von Moltke
Adam von Trott zu Solz
Notes
Chapter 1
1. The sources of this information and a more detailed examination of the organization
and personnel of the Rhodes secret society will be found in Chapter 3 below.
2. On Parkin, see the biography (1929) started by Sir John Willison and finished by
Parkin's son-in-law, William L. Grant. Also see the sketches of both Parkin and Milner in
the Dictionary of National Biography. The debate in the Oxford Union which first
brought Parkin to Milner's attention is mentioned in Herbert Asquith's (Lord Oxford and
Asquith) Memories and Reflections (2 vols., Boston, 1928), 1, 26.
3. The ideas for social service work among the poor and certain other ideas held by
Toynbee and Milner were derived from the teachings of John Ruskin, who first came to
Oxford as a professor during their undergraduate days. The two young men became
ardent disciples of Ruskin and were members of his road-building group in the summer
of 1870. The standard biography of Ruskin was written by a protege of Milner's, Edward
Cook. The same man edited the complete collection of Ruskin's works in thirty-eight
volumes. See Lord Oxford and Asquith, Memories and Reflections (2 vols., Boston,
1928), 1, 48. Cook's sketch in the Dictionary of National Biography was written by
Asquith's intimate friend and biographer, J. A. Spender.
4. The quotation is from Cecil Headlam, ed., The Milner Papers (2 vols., London,
1931-1933), I, 15. There exists no biography of Milner, and all of the works concerned
with his career have been written by members of the Milner Group and conceal more
than they reveal. The most important general sketches of his life are the sketch in the