Westphalen's brows went up. "That's either an attempt at redemption or a kid in a candy store. We may find out which one depending on what he's willing to tell us."
Reed had thought the same thing. "Tennant informed Tim of Tyler's death yesterday. He's traveling to Indianapolis today. Tennant will call me when he gets here."
"In the meantime," Mia said, "that leaves one person who knows what happened. Andrew Kates. We know he's in town. At least he was nine hours ago. He wanted Laura dead, so much he tried three times. He made mistakes with Caitlin, Niki Markov, and with Donna. And still he didn't get Laura. Ironically, he goofed with Penny, too."
"What do mean?" Spinnelli frowned. "She left him there a year."
"No. That didn't sit right with what everyone had told me about Penny. I went back and checked my notes and Reed, do you remember when we talked to Margaret Hill? Remember when she said she almost lost her mother when she was fifteen?"
"Yeah. She said her mother had been shot by a client. She almost died."
"Margaret Hill is twenty-five," Mia said. "You do the math."
"Oh," Reed breathed. She was right. "Penny Hill went into the hospital right about the time she placed Andrew and Shane in that home. She didn't forget about them. I bet her files got forwarded to other people and the kids fell through the cracks."
Mia nodded. "Then Shane dies and somebody says Oh shit. Andrew gets shuffled to another foster home and Shane gets swept under the rug."
"And his file disappears," Spinnelli said grimly. "This is bad for the state. I'll work it."
"That's fine. But back to Kates," Mia said. "Knowing how much he hates to miss his mark, what if he were to find out he'd goofed with Penny Hill? She never abandoned him. She wasn't even working the year he and Shane were at the Youngs'. Someone else dropped the ball with those boys. Someone else is to blame."
"So someone else should pay," Reed murmured, understanding her plan.
Spinnelli's smile started slow and grew. "I like this. We could draw him out."
"We'd have to set up some fake caseworker to take the fall," Mia said. "DCFS would have to cooperate."
"Leave that to me," Spinnelli said.
"And," she added, her own smile starting to spread, "it would have to get leaked to the press. By accident of course. And I wouldn't want to lie to any nice reporters."
"Of course not," Spinnelli repeated dryly. "So Wheaton's going down?"
"Oh yeah. I'll have to give her a little factual information, like Kates is angry because he was lost in foster care. Wheaton will dig deeper. It could get ugly."
"He's killed eleven people in my jurisdiction alone," Spinnelli said grimly. "Five more elsewhere, plus all those rapes. I want him stopped. Leak the story. Give his motive. Don't mention the dead brother or the lost file. We'll try to deal with that internally."
"Wheaton said she'd run that clip of Kelsey tonight at six, Marc," Mia said.
Spinnelli nodded. "You think you can pull off the crawl-and-grovel act, Mia?"
"Oh yeah. Wheaton'll think she has the biggest exclusive since Deep Throat."
"Then we wait for Kates to come to us," Reed finished.
She gave a single, satisfied nod. "And then we all live happily ever after."
Sunday, December 3, 11:15 A.M.
Mia walked up to Wheaton's table, angry belligerence in every step. Wheaton had insisted they meet in the same place she'd met Reed a few nights before.
Wheaton looked at Mia's clothing with disapproval. "I thought you'd dress."
Mia took a deliberate look at Wheaton's low-cut blouse. "I thought you would, too."
Wheaton's smile was feline. "Detective, that's hardly adult."
"Neither was sending me that video. And we both know it wasn't a mistake so just cut the bullshit." A lady at the next table gave her a glare.
"If you're done alienating the other diners," Wheaton drawled, "what do you want?"
Mia cocked her jaw. "Don't run that piece on my sister."
"Ah." Buttering her toast, Wheaton smiled. "I was wondering when you'd come to me. Well, that piece is set for tonight, opposite 60 Minutes."
She gritted her teeth. "Airing that tape will put my sister's life in danger"
"That can't be my concern. I'm a journalist."
Mia let her eyes flash. "Okay. Fine. What if you had an alternate story? One that would be bigger. More timely. That nobody else had. Yet."
Wheaton was interested. "Exclusive?"
Mia closed her eyes, made the word drag off her tongue. "Yes."
"What is it?"
"Tell me Kelsey's off the table."
"Can't do that." Wheaton leaned forward, rested her chin on her palm so that her perfect manicure showed perfectly. Her eyes sparkled. "You go first."
Mia drew a breath that was only part pretense. I hate you. I really hate you. "The second victim, Penny Hill, was a mistake. He missed his real target."
Wheaton's eyes narrowed. "Who was the real target?"
Mia set her teeth. Hesitated. "I… I can't do this. You go on the air with this and it paints a big bull's-eye on this person's head. I don't care what…" She got up. "I can't."
Wheaton sat back, eyes cool. "I've got an updated picture of Kelsey. The old one didn't look like her at all. And we girls do like to look our best. Most of us anyway."
Mia leaned forward as if fighting the urge to lunge, her hands curved into claws. But she calmed herself, stuck her hands in her pockets. "You're evil."
Wheaton shrugged. "We can help each other here. Your call, Detective. Either way, I have a really good piece of film. So either way, I win."
Mia closed her eyes. "Milicent Craven," she hissed through her teeth.
"Tell me why Kates is doing this."
Mia opened her eyes, made her face ashamed. "Penny Hill placed him in a foster home years ago. She got hurt, went on disability. His file was passed on to Craven, who dropped the ball, never checked him. Bad things happened to Kates in that home. This is about payback. But he paid back the wrong person."
Wheaton was quiet for so long Mia started to think she wouldn't take the bait at all. Then she nodded. "All right. If this pans out, your sister is off tonight's program."
Mia jerked a nod and turned.
"Oh, Detective Mitchell?" Mia turned back to find Wheaton smiling like the cat who'd swallowed the canary. "I'll see you again next week. Same theme song."
The bitch. "That's extortion," Mia murmured, so low the other diners couldn't hear.
"That's such an ugly word. I prefer 'partnership.' Well?"
"All right." Mia turned on her heel, walked out, then got in her car and after making sure she wasn't followed, pulled next to the police van parked a block away. She climbed inside and sat next to Reed. Jack had on headphones, watching the tape again.
"I almost didn't catch the extortion line," Jack complained.
Mia pulled the wire from under her shirt. "Sorry. I didn't want to scream it."
Reed lifted his brows. "I thought you were going to crawl and grovel."
"She wouldn't have bought it. I hate her too much and it's not my style. So do you think that's enough for Patrick to get an indictment?"
"Hope so," Jack said. "If not, she's just going to up the ante, making reports that threaten cops and their families to get information. We don't know thai she hasn't done it before, with other cops who might not have had the strength to say no."
"Or the support," Mia said quietly. "I'm just glad they moved Kelsey."
Jack started turning off his equipment. "Well, it's Sunday. I'm going to run this tape into the office and go home to my wife and kids. It's been fun, but leave now."
Mia smiled. "Say hi to Julia for me and kiss that baby."