Nilis said, “Quite right, Ensign. But look here…” The image magnified, until the center of the Baby Spiral loomed large and bright, and its crowded arms feathered off into the surrounding darkness. Nilis pointed to an unassuming speck of white light, just off-center from the spiral’s geometric heart. “Ensign Pirius, can you tell us what that is?”
“That’s Chandra. Sir, the Xeelee’s Galactic Prime Radiant is based at the three-million-stellar-mass black hole at the center of the Galaxy. The Xeelee seem to use it as their operational command post.”
Nilis nodded. “Good, good.”
“Yes,” said Luru Parz. “And a summary appropriately hedged with qualifications.”
Gramm glared at her. “What do you mean by that?”
“Seem to use it for this and that — Don’t you think it’s extraordinary, Minister, that after three thousand years of siege warfare around this Prime Radiant, we know so little about it, and indeed about our foe?”
Gramm turned away from her. “Make your point, Commissary.”
Nilis said, “My point is this.” He pointed dramatically to the display. “The Prime Radiant is surrounded by military targets, as you can see. But the Prime Radiant itself is not a target.” He looked at their faces, waiting for comprehension to dawn.
“And,” Gramm said around a mouthful of food, “you’re saying it should be.”
“Of course it should! The Prime Radiant is properly named, for it is in a real sense the source of the Xeelee presence in our Galaxy. And if we could strike at it—” He snapped his fingers again. Suddenly the center of the Baby Spiral glowed emerald green, and one by one the other lights went out. “Minister, take out the source, and all these other targets, which are downstream of it in a logical sense, are essentially taken out too. Why, it’s a question of economics. If you shut down the factory, you are saved the expense of picking off its products, one by one. Take out the power plant—”
“Yes, yes. Get on with it, man.”
“This, sir, is how I believe we should be fighting this war. What I’m asking for is the initiation of a new project. Its ultimate goal will be specific: the destruction of the Xeelee Prime Radiant.”
Through the fog of his verbiage, Nilis’s meaning suddenly became clear. Pirius felt a deep thrill run through him. To strike at the Prime Radiant itself!
The meeting was continuing. Pirius tried to focus.
Gramm picked his teeth. “What a wonderful imagination you must have, Commissary. But is that all you have?”
“Minister—”
“Do you imagine that in the long millennia of this war that nobody has come up with such an obvious tactic? Don’t you suppose that if it were ever possible it would have been done by now?”
“But if you won’t even think it through—”
Unexpectedly Gramm turned to Pirius. “Why don’t you take the floor, Ensign?”
“Sir?”
“You’re the hero of the hour. You downed a Xeelee; that’s why you’re here. Why don’t you explain to us why the Commissary’s suggestions are a fantasy? If I asked you to take out the Prime Radiant,
how would you respond?”
Pirius stayed where he was, uncertain and embarrassed. But Nilis shrugged and sat down.
So Pirius stood up, walked to the front of the room, and thought for a moment. He waved his hand to banish Nilis’s expensive Virtual displays, leaving only the whiteboard, and he picked up a stylus. With an apologetic glance at Nilis, he drew a red asterisk at the right hand side of the board. “Sir, I believe there are three fundamental problems. First, even if we could get through the Xeelee defenses in the region of Chandra” — he tapped the asterisk — “we don’t have any weapons that can strike at a black hole, and whatever the Xeelee are doing with it.”
“Of course not,” said Luru Parz. “How could we, since we’ve put no effort into finding out what the Prime Radiant actually is?… Go on, Ensign.”
Pirius drew a red circle around the asterisk. “Second problem. We can’t get through to Chandra anyhow, because if we could get close enough to engage the Xeelee’s inner defensive cordon, they would surely outfly us, outthink us. Their equipment is better than ours. Most important, their computing capability is superior.
“And third” — Pirius drew a dotted line reaching back to the left of the asterisk, and cut it through with a vertical line — “we can’t even get that close, because of FTL foreknowledge. The Xeelee would see us coming, and shoot us down before we left our bases.” He hesitated, looked at his sketch, and sat down.
He won an ironic slow clap from Gramm. “Admirably summarized.” The Minister raised an eyebrow at the Commissary. “Nilis? I hope you won’t claim now that you have a solution to all these problems?”
“No, sir. Not all of them. But, thanks to Pirius and his companions, I can solve one.” He walked to the whiteboard, picked up a stylus and tapped at the red circle Pirius had drawn around the Prime Radiant. “We may have a way to beat Xeelee processing power. It’s uncertain — Pirius Blue and his colleagues improvised it in the middle of combat — but we can take the concept, and build on it. Minister, we can outthink the Xeelee. I know that’s true, because we’ve done it once already. And if one of these ancient obstacles can at least in principle be overcome, then perhaps we can defeat the rest. Suddenly we see a chink of light; suddenly we have hope.”
Luru Parz was nodding. “Yes, yes. It was this strange news from the Front which drew my attention, too. A new hope.” And that was why she had forced her way into this meeting, Pirius saw, apparently over the objections of a Minister. Whoever this strange woman was, she had power — and her ambition seemed to be a mirror of Nilis’s.
Gramm glared at Nilis. “And that’s all you have to say? This is the case you’re going to make? Can you not see, Commissary, how you will make an enemy of almost everybody in authority if you go around claiming that better minds than yours have, for millennia, been pursuing the wrong targets — with the wrong weapons, too?”
Pirius saw that Nilis was struggling to control his anger. “Those ’better minds’ have been locked into a rigidity of thinking for all those long millennia, Minister.”
“Don’t go too far, Commissary,” Gramm said.
Nilis dismissed that with a wave. “I’m well aware that it wouldn’t be your decision alone, Minister, so let’s not play games. All I want at the beginning is seed-corn funding, enough to get us to proof-of- concept of the pilots’ new closed-timelike-curve computing paradigm. When that’s successfully demonstrated, we can move to the next stage, and ask for further funding to be released, stepwise. The political and financial control of the Coalition and the relevant Ministry over every stage of the project would be absolute—”
“You can bet your life it would,” Gramm shouted.
“Ask for more,” Luru Parz said immediately.
Nilis looked confused.
“Ask for more,” she said again. “We work in ignorance. We’ve seen that today. We have to start a new program of inquiry; we have to understand our enemy, at last. We can begin with your captive Xeelee, Commissary. But we have to find out more about them — especially their Prime Radiant — if we are to defeat them.”
Nilis had no choice but to nod. “You’re right, of course.”
Luru pressed Gramm. “Minister, these requests are undeniably reasonable — and politically, will be hard to refuse. After all, Nilis and his heroes and his captive Xeelee have made a real stir here on Earth. If there was no follow-up, questions would surely be asked. Even under the Coalition, public opinion counts for something.”