“ ‘Sure I’m sure,’ Jack said. ‘The day she came was my birthday. She made the best peach ice cream I’ve ever had, and she was nice to look at.’ These were Jack’s words, you understand. He told me that this cook named Mary stayed on to look after everyone who had come down with the fever. Not until they had all recovered did Mary return home. At that point it was mid-September.
“After that,” Soper said, “it was so simple, a child could have figured it out.” He described returning to Manhattan and contacting the agency the Warrens had used to find Mary. He had them send a list of all the other families Mary cooked for through the agency, in addition to the residence where she was currently employed.
“One by one the families got back to me reporting Typhoid outbreaks within a few weeks of Mary’s arrival. I assembled the data, and one afternoon in late February, I went over to the Bowen residence and rang the bell. I was willing at that point to believe it wasn’t her fault — as you know, there are still many doctors who cannot accept the theory of a healthy carrier — and I was prepared to explain it to her. I had not expected to be spoken to so rudely and threatened with a knife. I left a note for Mr. Bowen, but when I passed again several days later, I was shocked to see Mary’s head disappear into the servants’ entrance.”
“And what have you since learned about that note?”
“That the Bowens never received it.”
Mary could still see the flick of Frank’s wrist as he threw the note into the flames. The Bowens had fired him several weeks after Mary’s capture, and she hadn’t heard anything about him since. Fired for helping her, she considered once again and felt the guilt of that press up against her. Fired for knowing her. For being her friend.
“When did you next attempt to speak to Miss Mallon?” the lawyer asked.
“A week or so later, at the building where she lives on Thirty-Third Street.” Mary noticed that the courtroom seemed to darken around the edges of her vision, and she felt herself pull away. She felt all over again the shock of arriving home after a week’s work, just getting settled, hearing the knock on the door, and seeing Alfred open it to find Dr. Soper. “It’s very important that I speak with you,” he’d said, ignoring Alfred entirely and taking a slight step forward as if he’d been invited inside.
She sipped from the glass of water Mr. O’Neill nudged toward her.
“And?” the lawyer pushed.
Dr. Soper glanced in her direction so quickly that Mary wondered if she had imagined it. He smoothed the lapel of his jacket.
“And I was unsuccessful. Neither she nor her companion would listen. It’s possible that the first time I met Miss Mallon I was too abrupt, too scientific about the problem. I’ll grant that. I had a sense of urgency when I went to see her at the Bowen residence, and perhaps I didn’t consider her feelings. When I visited her at her own rooms, I tried a different tack. When she saw it was me at her door, she shouted, ‘What do you want with me?’ So I asked her very calmly, ‘Haven’t you noticed that disease and death follow you wherever you go?’ ”
He was telling the truth about what he’d said, but Mary remembered his tone, and it wasn’t calm. It was an accusation. Still standing at the door, Alfred had looked back and forth between them, and then stepped away. She remembered shouting, but not what she’d said. She remembered that he seemed to grow more calm as she got more upset.
“And what was her response?”
“Anger, as far as I could tell. Once again, she came after me with a knife.”
A knife with a blade so dull it could barely cut butter, Mary thought. She’d wanted to argue with him that day, but she couldn’t make sense of what he was saying, couldn’t get past the jolt of seeing him again. Disease and death didn’t follow her any more than they followed anyone else. People had been dying her whole life. First her father, in a fire. Then her mother, of a cough. Then, a few years later, her brother, then her other brother, then her sister in childbirth, then her sister’s two babies, and then her beloved nana while Mary was en route to America. Had they had fevers? She supposed they had, but she couldn’t remember, and anyway, those sicknesses that kill a person always come with fever, and in Ireland they didn’t name their fevers. People became sick. They died. She never heard the word Typhoid until she came to America.
“Was this the first time you learned that she had a companion?” The attorney checked his notes. “Mr. Alfred Briehof?”
“Yes.”
“And what can you tell us about that?”
“When I first arrived at the address the agency had provided to me, I saw Mary outside on the stoop, presumably having just arrived home. I was about to announce myself, but a man approached and embraced her. On the street. I assumed she was engaged to be married, but I’ve since discovered that she is not. It was Mr. Briehof who answered my knock when I tried to speak to her at the door to their rooms not ten minutes later.”
“Can you describe their rooms from what little you saw?”
“Mr. Briehof appeared disheveled. I noted dirty dishes on the press, and there was an odor of overripe fruit.”
The attorney continued. “Please describe to us what you did after failing for a second time to convince Miss Mallon that she must come in for testing.”
“I leaned more heavily on the Department of Health and the NYPD to take action because I knew I would need their help. After finally persuading them, we came up with a plan. We enlisted a female doctor to help, hoping Mary would be more willing to cooperate with a female, but that was not the case.”
“And that doctor was Josephine Baker, correct?”
“Yes.”
Mary scanned the people on the other side of the room, but didn’t see Dr. Baker among them.
• • •
Judge Erlinger called for a lunch recess at noon. Mr. O’Neill suggested they eat together, but Mary wanted to spend the three-quarters of an hour with Alfred. Mr. O’Neill started to protest that they had items to go over, but then he relented. “I have to send a guard,” he said. Mary found Alfred leaning against the back wall of the courtroom, watching her approach. She felt the damp wrinkles in her clothes as she moved closer to him, a rumpled sack of laundry that should be pushed into a basin and wrung out to dry. Her hair had collapsed; she could feel it bobbing at the back of her neck. She was nervous.
Alfred took her hand and squeezed it once before leading her into the hall and down the steps outside to the corner, where a man with a pushcart was selling ham sandwiches. The guard stayed a few paces behind. What was it that was different about him? He pulled off his collar and unbuttoned his shirt. He pulled off the shirt’s cuffs, rolled up the sleeves, and threw the collar and cuffs in the bushes. Without them, Mary saw that the shirt was worn so thin it was little more than gauze, the outline of his undershirt obvious in the sun. He moved his hand to her waist. She had decided that she wouldn’t let him kiss her until she’d said her piece, but now that the moment had arrived, she decided she could spend the rest of her life saying her piece. She hadn’t seen him in so long, and here he was, looking and smelling and moving like Alfred. She waited, but he only touched her cheek.
“I have only half an hour myself,” Alfred said.
“Work?” She doubted it — what job would allow him to show up after noon? — but it was a day for letting things go, for keeping peace. She wanted him to look forward to her release, not dread it.
Alfred nodded. “It started as a day-to-day thing, but they’ve not said anything about stopping, so I keep showing up and they keep paying me. It’s going on six months now.”
“What is it?”
“The ice trucks. Or rather, the ice company stable. They let me drive the truck last week when a man was out, but that was just for the week.”