The girls all got it.
“The last guy is one of my best friends. His name’s Jeff and he’s a freshman. Jeff is six feet tall and one of the smartest guys I know. We’re proud that we are fellow nerds. These guys have been selected because they are all gentlemen. You’ll be perfectly safe with them. But if you’re looking for a little fun beyond dancing, I’m sure you can talk them into some extracurricular activities.”
“You left someone out,” one of the girls said.
I looked confused and Tami smirked.
“You, ‘stupid boy.’”
“Oh, sorry. I’m David and I’m a freshman who plays quarterback on our varsity. I’m six-two and weigh one hundred ninety-five pounds. My plan is to go with the girl who asked me, Tami. If Tami wants every dance, she’ll be in my arms. If she decides to take a break, I’d be happy to dance with any one of you.”
Tami blushed. I figured I’d give them something to talk about.
“I love you, Tami. Just say the word and I’m yours.”
“I love you too,” she said. “You go take care of Kyle, and I’ll talk to you tomorrow.”
I signed off and took Kyle back to his bed. I crawled into my own bed and I fell asleep quickly.
I woke to being kissed. At first, the kiss was gentle and teasing, but soon things heated up. I felt her body cover mine and her legs straddle my waist. She was wearing panties and a t-shirt with no bra. I felt myself swell. I reached down and grabbed her butt, and was kneading it when the lights came on. I heard Greg cough. I opened my eyes to find Angie stop kissing me.
“Oh shit. Greg, I’m so sorry.”
I suddenly realized my hands were on his girlfriend’s butt, and I jerked them off.
Angie looked at Greg.
“I know this was to get us even, but damn, can I sleep with him?”
“Not tonight,” Greg laughed. “You don’t have to convince me. It’s David who’ll have to be talked into it. He’ll have questions that need to be answered before he’d do that.”
Cindy came up to Angie.
“Bad! Mine! Get off of my boy-toy before you break him.”
“Give me a quick one so I can get to sleep,” Angie pouted.
I looked over at Greg and he nodded. He came over to the bed and got Kyle and left.
“Are you sure? Is Greg okay?” Cindy asked Angie.
“We’ve talked about it. David’s the only guy Greg trusts to be with me.”
I looked at both of them.
“Nope, not gonna happen. If you girls want to play, that’s fine with me, but count me out.”
Both girls squealed and were naked in record time.
I got up and grabbed a pair of shorts. I could tell that these two had done this type of thing before.
“You tease. Get to work! Momma needs to get off,” Angie said, which cracked me up.
I made a hasty retreat to the living room. I only had so much self-control.
When the girls were done, Cindy came and got me. Angie was down for the count. I sent Greg a text to come see Cindy’s handiwork. He came back and shook his head at his girlfriend who was sound asleep in my bed. Of course, my apartment smelled of sex. Angie started to come around. Greg rolled her on her stomach so she couldn’t see him, and he took her from behind.
“David NO!”
Her head snapped around and, when she saw Greg, she got a big grin. I pulled out a condom, envying Greg for being able to take Angie bareback. Their hips were making a staccato slapping sound as they had sex.
Cindy smiled at me.
“How do you want it?” I asked her.
Her liquid eyes showed her passion.
“Slow and easy, lover.”
I sat on my calves and lifted her butt to pull her onto Mr. Happy. Angie smiled at me and took Cindy’s hand, and I began to rock back and forth as I found her depths. Every time I slept with Cindy, it was a special thrill. To see this gorgeous woman have sex was mind-blowing. She could have anyone, and she picked me. She and I made slow, passionate love. It was exactly what we both needed.
Greg and Angie finished first, got dressed, and left. We continued our lovemaking at a gentle pace, and Cindy had several small orgasms. When I had mine, we were both grinning like idiots. I disposed of the condom and brought back a warm washcloth so Cindy could clean up. We came together in bed, and she wrapped herself around my body as we settled into sleep. We were both asleep within moments of our heads hitting the pillow.
Chapter 4 – The List
Tuesday November 5
I WOKE TO MY ALL-TIME favorite thing, a woman giving me oral sex. It was the best alarm clock ever invented. I was close, and when she sensed that I was awake, she really started to work me over. Unfortunately, I couldn’t last under her onslaught.
“Hmmm, I needed that,” Cindy purred.
Okay, I can live with satisfying her needs if it means she’s going to give me oral. She crawled up my body, put her head on my chest, and rubbed her hand on my stomach. She had a stray hair that I hooked behind her ear.
“Tell me what happened last night,” I asked.
“I talked to Angie. She was afraid that she was losing Greg. I told her about your concerns, and Greg came in. When he heard you were worried, he paid attention. They talked everything out. Angie was pissed about him hitting on Kara. Greg accused her of having the hots for you. She admitted that she thought you were sexy and wouldn’t mind getting into your pants. Somehow, she convinced him to allow you to be on her list.”
“What list?”
“They each get three people they can be with. The other gets veto power. Greg was trying to goad Angie by picking me. Angie just laughed at him and said she was fine with that. She then picked you. I don’t think Greg thinks you’d ever go through with it, so he said fine. He then picked someone else, and I threatened to cut his nuts off.”
“Let me guess: Kara.”
She twisted her head so she could see if I was mad.
“Yes. I told him that if he did that to you, I’d never talk to him again. Angie gave it her veto, so Kara isn’t on the list.”
“Who else is on their lists?”
“No one yet. Angie wanted to test things out and see if she and Greg could bring others into their sex life. She made a rule about no penetration with a guy she’s with. That was genius.”
“Why do you say that?”
“Two reasons,” Cindy said. “First of all, the male ego doesn’t handle seeing their girlfriend having sex with another man very well. Women tend to handle it better. However, if Angie’s going to be your future sister-in-law, I would have a problem watching,” she said.
I wasn’t sure how I felt about that.
“The second is that you and Greg are very similar. Angie fell for Greg hard. It would be easy for her to fall for you, too. The key to the list working is keeping sex and love separate. You have to know that your partner loves you and that you’re confident in that love. If you ever slept with Angie, we’d have a problem.”
Greg and Angie came into my room and Angie looked well-rested. Greg must have let her sleep through the night, or Kyle finally let them rest.
“Look at these two,” Angie said. “I wanted to thank you for last night. It was exactly what we both needed.”
She hugged Greg, and he nodded to me, letting me know everything was good. Cindy looked at the clock, gave me a quick kiss, and then started to get dressed.
“Shit, I have to get home and get ready for school.”
She was out the door in a flash.
After Cindy left, Angie sat down on the bed and touched my hand.
“David, are you okay with what happened last night? We don’t want you feeling weird about anything.”
“No, not really. I mean, last night was spur-of-the-moment, and I think everyone had a good time, but I think it should just be a one-time deal. I don’t think I’m the guy for your list.”
“Oh, thank God!” Greg said as he let out a long breath.