“What?”
“Your blood.”
The anger was a flood, drowning my words.
“I can’t believe you,” I finally choked out. “Literally, I can’t believe this is happening. You’re my sister. How the hell can you do this to me?”
“It’s not my fault he doesn’t want you anymore. None of this is my fault.”
“It’s all your fault!” I screamed. “You should have been the one in that car. It should have been you!”
The world froze.
I’d never said it out loud before. I’d promised myself. I wouldn’t say it, I wouldn’t think it, I wouldn’t feel it. I would not blame her. I wouldn’t process the ifs. If she’d been in the car, if she’d died that day instead of me. I would still have my body. I would still have my boyfriend. I would still have my life.
I couldn’t take it back.
Walker put an arm around her shoulder.
“Sorry to disappoint you,” she said slowly, her voice cold. “But it wasn’t me. It was you.” I didn’t know what she was thinking. We were sisters, but I never knew what she was thinking. She wrapped her arm around Walker’s waist. “Let’s go,” she murmured. He nodded.
“I’m sorry,” he said again, over his shoulder as they walked away.
She never turned back.
I don’t know how I ended up on the ground. But suddenly that’s where I was, sitting with my back to the wall, only a few feet from where they’d been kissing.
Auden sat next to me. I still couldn’t look at him. Not that I wanted him to go—but I didn’t want him to stay, either. I didn’t want anything except to not know. My brain was a computer: It should have been possible to delete.
“He’s not good enough for you,” Auden said finally.
I wanted to laugh. Such a lame cliché. True—but still lame.
“And your sister… You know she didn’t mean what she said.”
“She meant it,” I said flatly. Zo had only told one lie that afternoon—that she didn’t hate me. Because obviously she did. Fine. That made us even.
“Okay, so she’s a bitch and he’s an asshole.” Auden looked hopeful. “Does that help?”
I had to laugh. “No. But thank you.”
“Do you think—No, never mind.”
“What?” I asked.
“It’s none of my business.”
“Auden, I think we’ve just established you’re the only one I’ve got. So if it’s not your business, then whose would it be?”
“I was just wondering…” He hesitated. “I mean, you’re obviously upset.”
“You noticed.”
“Is it because you still… I mean, if Walker wanted to get back together, would you…?”
“You want to know if I’m still in love with him?” I asked.
He nodded. “But like I say, it’s not really my business, so…”
“It’s fine.” I just wasn’t sure how to answer. “I’m over him, I think,” I said, and it felt true. “If he was with someone else, anyone but—” I couldn’t say it out loud. Instead I lowered my head and pressed the heels of my hands over my eyes. “What he said, about being willing to try? He was. And what if he’s the only one who… What if no other guy… I mean, who would want me like this?”
His hand brushed my neck, flitted to my shoulder, then disappeared. “He’s not the only one.”
“Whatever.”
“No. Lia. I’ve been waiting to—I mean, I didn’t know how—I have to tell you—” The hand was back, resting firmly on my shoulder this time, heavy. “He’s not the only one who would. Want you. Like this.”
Shit.
“Auden, you don’t have to—”
But he wouldn’t stop.
“I know you probably don’t see me like that,” he said, talking quickly, like if he paused for breath he wouldn’t get himself going again, although I guess that was too much to ask for. “But I think you’re amazing and when I’m with you, it’s like we really understand each other, you know, and I think you’re beautiful, you’re more beautiful like this than you ever were before—”
Not now, I thought, furious with him, furious with myself. Not now, when I need you. Don’t do this.
“I know I shouldn’t say anything, I know, I always say something, I always ruin things, I should just let it happen, but I can’t let you think that no one would—because I would, I do, I just…” His entire body had gone rigid. “What do you think?”
“I’m a little… This has been a weird day for me,” I said, stalling. “You know, with—” I glanced toward the spot they’d been leaning against, where I imagined I could still see their afterimage bright against the bricks.
“I know.” He shook himself all over. “I know. It was stupid. Bad timing.”
Damn right. But, “No, it’s okay.”
“It’s not okay. It’s stupid. I shouldn’t have thought—”
I kissed him.
Because he wanted me to. Because he wanted me. Because no one else did. Because he’d saved me, more than once.
Because why not?
And in the fairy tale that’s it, the end, happily ever after.
In the fairy tale they never mention the part about your tongues scraping against each other or your foreheads bumping or your nose getting bent and flattened or his tongue just sitting there in your mouth, limp and wet, and then spinning around like a pinwheel, bouncing back and forth between your fake palate and your porcelain teeth. In the fairy tale they never mention how it tastes, although to me it didn’t taste like anything at all.
I’m not saying he was a bad kisser.
I’m not saying he was great, because he wasn’t. But I’m not saying it was his fault, even though maybe it was. Or maybe it was mine.
I’m just saying it was bad.
Worse than bad. It was nothing. Like kissing my own balled-up fist, as I’d done for practice when I was a kid. I wanted not to care, to just go with it, because it would have been so easy, it would have made him happy, and it would have made me… not alone.
When our faces separated, he was smiling, his eyes glazed and dewy, his mouth half open, like he wasn’t sure whether to speak or to lunge in for another round.
“I’m sorry,” I said as gently as I could. “I can’t.”
“Did I do something wrong?”
“No!” I said quickly. “I just don’t think it’s a good idea.”
He sagged, a deflated balloon. “I should have known you would never… not with me.”
“It’s not that,” I said. “It’s just too much right now.”
“You don’t have to say that,” he said bitterly. “I know I’m not Walker. I do have a mirror, you know. I get it.”
“It’s not you.” I wanted to touch him, to shake him. “Everything’s so… screwed up. And I’m”—I gestured down at myself, at the body—“I’m different. We’re different, and I don’t think the two of us…”
“Is this about what that guy said? Jude?” Auden’s fingers flickered across the bandage on his palm. “I told you, he doesn’t know what he’s talking about.”
“It’s not about what he said. It’s what I know. This wouldn’t work. And if it didn’t…” Now I did touch him—I took his hand. He pulled away. “I don’t want to mess this up, what we have. I can’t risk that.”
“Why not?” He was edging toward a whine. “If you really want something, sometimes it’s worth taking a chance.”
But what if you really didn’t want something?
“It’s not going to work, Auden.”
“Because you don’t want it to work,” he snapped.
“Because it won’t!” Why couldn’t he just let it go? “Stop pushing it!”