That was a huge mistake. I knew this, when, her nostrils flared and her eyes flashed wild.
“He what?!”
“Sierra, you know about that. The night of the beach party.”
Maybe Lexi had been right. Sierra’s eyes were flashing wild, and if I could have seen her face better, there might have been some foam at the corner of her mouth.
“So you’re telling me that the only reason you kissed me that night was because Chris dared you?!”
I sighed. There was no way I was getting out of this. “No, of course not. The reason we kissed was because of the stupid game. And then, after we left the closet, he whispered in my ear, daring me to kiss you.”
“So, once again, you only kissed me because he dared you to?”
Someone could’ve handed me a shovel then. I was apparently in the mood to dig my own grave.
“Are you bleeding?” The words slipped out before I could stop them. I was usually really good in these types of situations. I was sort of a PMS-whisperer. I always knew what to do and say to make sure my head wasn’t ripped off by one of the three close girls in my life. And, typically, Sierra was the least hormonal.
Apparently, this was no longer the case.
“Did you seriously just ask me that?”
“Umm, no?” I replied innocently, hoping she’d think she’d heard me wrong.
She didn’t.
She crossed the distance between us and jabbed a finger into my chest. I wince at her hard poke.
“As a matter of fact, I am. What of it?!”
My hand rose and enclosed her little finger. I placed my other one on the small of her back and pulled her lower half into me. She stared up at me, and I hated when her eyes glistened with tears. So I leaned down and planted a chaste kiss on her forehead.
“I’m sorry, Sierra. I shouldn’t have said that.”
She sniffled, and I took it as a sign to keep going.
“Baby, we’ve been together for nearly three years. Best friends for much longer than that. I think you know how I feel about you. I love you more than I ever thought I could love anyone. And, every single day, I fall more in love with you. Is it true that Chris dared me to kiss you? Yes. It is. But he did it because he knew I’d been in love with you longer than I could even admit to myself. He knew I was too chickenshit, too scared to do it on my own. So he gave me that little push, and I fucking took it. And I’ve never looked back. I never will.”
“Chris knew before you did?” she asked, her voice shaky.
“I think everyone knew before we did, don’t you think?”
“True.”
Relief flooded my veins. “So you see why I can’t not accept Chris’s dares? And plus, it’s kinda perfect. We’ll be an authentic eighties couple.”
Even though she tried to frown, a small smile played on her lips. Her finger dug harder into my chest. “I am not going to my senior prom with some Billy Ray wannabe.”
I frowned and took a step back, clutching my chest and feigning horror. “I am not, nor will I ever want to be, Billy Ray Cyrus.”
She placed her hands back on her hips and raised an eyebrow at me. I stepped closer to her, and she stepped back.
“You can call me MacGyver.”
“No,” she answered firmly as she set her chin in defiance.
I closed the distance between us and grasped her waist, bringing her in closer. Then I dipped my head and whispered a kiss on her lips before moving mine to hover over her ear. “How about John Stamos?”
She shuddered as my breath tickled her ear, and I knew I had her. When I pulled away, she was struggling not to smile. Her hands slid up my chest and wrapped around my neck. She used her fingers to toy with my hairline as if she were trying to imagine what I’d look like with a mullet.
“John Stamos,” I whispered again, grinning down at her.
“I guess I can work with that,” she finally relented.
Uncle Jesse for the win.
I’d been livid when I’d found out about Chris’s not-so-brilliant plan. And even more livid when Lexi had informed me that Jeremy had accepted the dare. In hindsight, I had been a little angrier than the situation had called for, and even though Jeremy had oh-so-astutely pointed it out, it was definitely the hormones.
He’d been growing out his hair for the past couple of months, but he refused to get it cut or styled until the day of prom. He wanted it to be a surprise, not only for me, but for everyone. I was both nervous and excited to see how it turned out. At the end of the day, it didn’t matter what his hairstyle was like. All that mattered was that we were together, we had fun, and we spent the night making memories we’d fondly remember for the rest of our lives.
“Oh, Lexi,” I breathed out, very reminiscent of what she’d done the day I had gone to my first dance with Jeremy. “You look beautiful.”
“You think?” she asked nervously as she smoothed her skirt out.
I’d joined in with Jeremy on the ’80s theme, having lucked out that Mom still had an old bridesmaid dress that was pink, poofy, and utterly ridiculous. I loved it. Lexi, however, had decided to stick with the times. The svelte, black dress she’d chosen fit her slim frame perfectly. White flowers adorned the left side. It made her tan skin glow and accentuated her best features.
“Absolutely. You look amazing,” I informed her, giving her another once-over. “Jace’s jaw is going to drop to the floor when he sees you. I hope I’m there to witness it.”
Her eyes raced to meet mine, and she brought her hands to her stomach. “Jace? I’m going with Aaron. You know that.”
I waved her off. “Whatever. I’ve seen the way both guys watch you. Jace will definitely be checking you out.”
“Sierra, how many times do I have to tell you?”
“You’re just friends, blah. You know, that’s what Jeremy and I always said.”
“It doesn’t matter. He’s going to Alabama in the fall.”
I rolled my eyes. “Tuscaloosa isn’t that far away. And isn’t that more of a reason to tell him how you feel now?”
She let out a heavy sigh. “I’m with Aaron.”
I wanted to grasp her shoulders and shake some sense into her, but if she wanted to live in denial, I guess she’d have to figure it out for herself. I just hoped it would happen sooner rather than later.
“Okay, okay. I’ll shut up about it.”
Lexi cleared her throat and darted towards the hall. “Excuse me. I need to retouch my mascara,” she said, not looking in my direction.
It was my turn to sigh. Perhaps I’d been wrong in not letting Jeremy meddle. Jace and Lexi had been riding this friendship train for way too long, and it was only a matter of time until it derailed.
“Oh, honey, you look so beautiful.” Mom standing in the doorway. “And that dress looks better on you than it ever did on me.”
I grinned. “Oh, I don’t know about that. Maybe one day you can wear it to my wedding,” I teased.
She laughed, shaking her head. “I can’t believe my little girl is going to her last school dance,” Mom said, wiping at the corners of her eyes. “It feels like just yesterday that Jeremy was picking you up for homecoming. And here you are, nearly three years later. Soon, you’ll be graduating and starting your own life. I’m not old enough for this.”
I smiled at her. “You knew even back then that Jeremy and I would end up together, didn’t you?”
“Honey, if you think Lydia and I haven’t been planning your wedding for years, you’re crazy.” She laughed, and I couldn’t tell if she was serious or not. But, knowing our moms, I was pretty sure she was serious.
“Do you think it’s crazy? That I found the person I want to spend my life at the age of eight? I know in my heart that Jeremy’s it for me. Is that insane?”