“It is, because after she told me I checked.” The boat slipped sideways, turning in circles down the river. “You know them — they’re very close, like us, and they don’t keep secrets from each other. One day Blanche was in their hay loft doing something with the bales, and she heard Sandy on the ladder. She told me she was afraid and she didn’t know why. They got to fooling around and before she knew what was happening Sandy lifted up her dress and said, ‘What have you got down there?’”
“He didn’t!”
“He sure did. But that wasn’t all. Instead of pushing him away she just laughed—”
“She never laughs.”
“This was different. Sandy was reaching and kissing her so hard Blanche said her teeth hurt. She felt him pulling her bloomers. After a while she told him to stop, which he did.”
“That’s only right,” said Orlando and thrashed with his oars.
“But neither of them—”
“There’s more of this?” He lifted his oars at me.
“Neither of them was really sorry, and after a day or so they were at it again, going to town in the hay loft, just the two of them. Blanche said it was funny — she had always dreamed about it happening like that, and she had sort of rehearsed it in her mind. So, once they started, they carried on, and she couldn’t stop it then even if she had wanted to, which she didn’t. He had a good grip on her and she closed her eyes and they did it.”
“Did what?” he said hoarsely.
“Jammed.”
“Maude, I’ve never heard you talk like this.”
“Like nobody’s business,” I said, nodding with approval.
“That damned girl.”
“She was glad — you can’t blame her,” I said. And I told him that Blanche was especially tickled that it had happened with Sandy, because love is knowledge and no one knows more than a brother and sister.
“Blanche?” he said. “Tickled?” We were under a bridge and Orlando’s voice leaped at us from the granite pillars and arches in a gulping echo. We were still drifting, nudged by the eddies at the pillars and losing our spin as we cleared the bridge.
“Of course she cried, but that was sheer happiness and gratitude. She wasn’t afraid anymore and she told me that as long as she lives she will never forget it and never love anyone as much as Sandy. Which I can understand. Can’t you?”
“And she told you this?”
“She showed me the bites and bruises. They were beautiful, like purple pansies stamped on her skin.”
He looked mystified. The oars rested limply in his hands and the blades dragged on the water.
I said, “I don’t hold it against her.”
“No,” he said wearily, “not if she loved him.”
“And I know how she feels.” I was hoping to extract a response from him, but none came. I said, “Do you know how she feels?”
He faced me. His answer made his eyes blaze and heated my face and dried my tears. He said, “Yes, I do!”
“Think of it,” I said. “Just the two of them together.”
“There’s no room for anyone else,” he said, turning cautious.
“Exactly — that’s the beauty of it.”
“What did their parents say?”
He wanted more reassurance, but I couldn’t give it. I said I didn’t know, but I told him my views on that, how at a certain age your parents exhaust themselves of knowledge: you outgrow them and have to begin raising them, keeping certain things from them.
He said, “I thought you were so proper.”
“Ollie, they’re just like us! What is more proper than a brother and sister in bed in their own house? It fits exactly. People go through life trying to find the perfect partner and never realize that that person is back home — the one they left. It’s their own flesh and blood. It’s so simple I don’t know why more people don’t do it.”
He said, “Because there’s a law against it, cookie.”
“The law hates lovers,” I said.
“Tell that to the judge,” he said. “Listen, even primitive societies are against it.”
“But they’re against everything that’s sensible — that’s why they’re primitive. But there’s nothing primitive about the Pratts.”
He said, “I thought we were talking about the Overalls.”
“We’re talking about brothers and sisters,” I said. “People like you and me.”
He spoke to the gunwale: “I didn’t think you could get away with things like that.”
“So you’ve thought about it.”
“Of course I have,” he said. I thought he was going to amplify this, but all he said was, “Blanche had me fooled.”
“And me. The funny thing is, ever since she told me I’ve liked her more. I didn’t think she had it in her. You think people are different, but they’re not — they’re as strange as you. I know how she feels, don’t you?”
He considered his thumbs. He said, “I’m glad you told me.”
The wind stirred his hair, an agitation like a process of thought.
He said, “Why am I so happy all of a sudden?”
“Ollie,” I said, and kissed him and took his picture: that expression of intense thought draining away and leaving his face lively and untroubled. The sun had set his hair smoldering, and I was soused with sunbeams.
He looked up and saw that we had drifted to the Boston shore. He straightened and gripped the oars and swung the boat around smartly, then — and I could see that it had sunk in — started back to Harvard with swift decisive strokes.
PART THREE
14. Fellow Travelers
HE WAS back. He returned to Grand Island in the middle of the night and used his own key to make poking clacks at the keyhole, like a burglar’s tired attempt at an inside job. I opened my eyes, blinked away the rust, and rose from the luminosity and chatter of a dream to the dark stillness of the house. It disturbed me: I surfaced, I opened my mouth, the dream trembled, and everything was black.
His noises made him big and busy, a lumbering body. He snapped on lights as he moved from room to room, and then there was that sequence of sounds you only hear at night, that makes its own brief pictures. A door shut and bolted; a spattering jet of bubbles propelled into a bowl; the uncorking of a valve and a chain’s releasing rattle; a collapse of water pressure in the pipes and a fugitive hiss and suck in the walls. The snap, snap, snap of light switches; the complaining stair plank; the resonant crunch of bedsprings; the latecomer’s surrendering sigh in his soft bed.
I subsided into sleep myself and did not wake again until I heard a South Yarmouth lawnmower rat-tatting across the agitated blue of the Sound. It was a beautiful autumn day, a breeze making the sunlight leap from the spiky waves like fire in crystal, and all the long grasses on the dunes brushing softly against the breeze’s belly, He was in and out of the windmill, in and out, the slap of feet and doors, scrabbling in the picture palace. Though in bed I could believe that forty years hadn’t happened — one’s bed is the past — I got up on one elbow and saw him through the window, striding across the lawn with boxes of photographs, carrying my work into the house to examine. I sprang up, put on my housecoat and slippers, and shuffled downstairs into the present.
“You’re at it bright and early, Frank.”
He muttered something about the night bus.
I said, “You strike bottom yet?”
“There’s a hell of a lot more where these came from.” I saw a crude form of criticism, a kind of impatience, in the way he tossed his hair to the side, but his forelock flopped back into his eyes. “If you ask me, I don’t think they’ve ever been touched.”
“I’m counting on you to do that,” I said. “For the life of me, I can’t imagine how they got there.”