“As soon as Rose arrived in Italy, she fell ill and was confined to her bed. Rose never even learned of the accident that killed their parents; she died soon after.
“Renata was a wealthy English girl studying art in Florence. She and Dorothy were close before, but inseparable after Rose’s death. When Dorothy decided to return to America, she convinced Renata to join her- as Rose.”
“Why not as herself?” I asked.
“It was an accident, really. Renata used Rose’s return ticket onboard ship. The purser knew, of course, but everyone else thought the two were sisters. They decided to continue the ruse after arriving in Springfield. That way they could live together and no one would suspect.”
“Nobody noticed?”
“Their social circle was small. They didn’t see the butcher and the mailman every day the way you or I would. And William was such a small child when Rose left, he wouldn’t have known.”
“And when they had their annual party,” I added, “Renata stayed indoors, watching from the library.” That part I’d read in the papers. “Which was the reason everyone believed she was sickly.”
“Just in case,” Hillary said. She took a deep breath. “Lesbianism wasn’t chic in those days, the twenties were over and the seventies hadn’t arrived yet. They said William was crushed when he found out. He was only a boy, fourteen or fifteen when he left Springfield, bitter, confused, and vowing to never return.”
“Did he ever return?”
“He might have come back once-I can’t say for sure. I was rather young at the time. The sisters always spoke so fondly of him. They kept thinking he’d show up one day, and then their little family would be complete.”
“People seemed to think he went west.”
“That’s possible; a lot of people did in those days.”
“It can’t have been easy to keep up a charade like that for so many years. I feel rather sorry for them,” I said.
“They had each other and friends, I believe, in other cities.”
“That would account for the trips to out- of- town specialists.”
“Yes. Everyone’s life is different,” she added a little sadly. “Don’t feel too sorry for them. They brought each other a lot of joy. Not many heterosexual couples stay together for over sixty years.” She straightened up in her chair, possibly thinking of her own unhappy marriage.
“There were some in town who knew, or suspected, but they kept quiet-after all, it’s nobody else’s business. It was courageous of them to defy convention like that at a time when most folks didn’t.” She briefly disappeared into her own thoughts.
“In any event, the sisters were wonderful to us, which is why Gerry and I don’t like hearing the assumptions people are making.”
“Ms. Gibson, something even more serious has happened. Guido Chiaramonte has been stabbed and Hugo Jurado has been arrested.”
She hadn’t heard.
“No one who knows Hugo would believe him capable of that. I think it’s possible the baby I found may have something to do with Guido’s stabbing.” I trod carefully. “Since you don’t think either of the sisters was the mother, have you any thoughts on who the mother might be?”
“I’ll assume you’re including me on your list of suspects, but you can cross me off. I can’t have children.”
I hoped I didn’t look too disappointed. And I hoped she was telling the truth. “It sounds like not many strangers had access to the property, so it was very likely someone they knew,” I said.
“Over so many years that could be a hundred people.”
“A special friend or art student?” I suggested.
“Not that I can recall.”
“Someone who worked there, maybe in the garden?”
“They didn’t keep live- in help, but I couldn’t say for sure. After all, I haven’t been a local for almost thirty years.”
“Oddly enough, that may be just the right time frame.”
“Guido Chiaramonte.” She shook her head. “A thoroughly disreputable man. I probably shouldn’t say it, but it’s a wonder somebody didn’t stab him years ago.”
Perhaps Hillary knew another candidate? “Did you see much of him when you lived in Springfield?” I asked, wondering if she could have been another of his old flames.
“I wouldn’t say much. Let’s see, I was away at school when he moved here, so I suppose it was when I was home on holidays. He always seemed to be there at the Fifields’, hovering and leering. I don’t think he suspected the sisters’ true relationship,” she said. “That would have been beyond his comprehension.
“I’ll give it some more thought,” she said, “but you should talk to Gerry. He has some very different ideas on the subject. I said as much to Sergeant O’Malley. He was here yesterday.”
The sound of a vehicle crunching gravel in the driveway brought the interview to a close. “You’ll have to excuse me now,” she said, getting up. “That must be my architect.”
“Thank you for seeing me. I will call Mr. Fraser.”
She walked me to the door.
“It’s a wonderful house,” I said politely. “What are you having done?”
“I’m putting in an elevator. A friend of mine has trouble with stairs.”
CHAPTER 30
From the porch of the Sunnyview Nursing Home, a resident would have a good view of both Morning Glory Cemetery and the Springfield Recycling Center. I wondered if the old folks appreciated the constant reminders that we’re all future compost. Gerald Fraser saw me pull into the driveway, and he waved me over to where he sat, tapping his gimpy leg to keep the circulation going.
It was a far cry from the picture I’d gotten of him last night. On the passenger seat of my Jeep, stuck in between nursery receipts and old copies of Garden Design, were the attachments I’d finally printed out from Lucy’s e-mail of the week before: two articles from the New York Times and two from the Bulletin.
The first Times article had a cropped picture of Gerald Fraser’s graduating class at the police academy, with Fraser’s head circled. Wrestler’s body, thick brows, superhero jawline, and million- watt smile. Full of testosterone and good intentions. The headline read: CT COP SAVES JOGGER IN PARK.
On March 17, 1976, Fraser and some other local cops had been in New York for the St. Paddy’s Day Parade. After a busy day marching and partying, Fraser and a few of his buddies were watering some bushes in the north end of Central Park when they surprised two guys attacking a woman. Fraser zipped up the fastest and took off after the assailants. He managed to subdue them both but not before being stabbed in the leg so viciously the doctors thought he’d never walk again. And never be a cop again. They were only half- right. The second Times attachment was one line in the Metro Briefing section, HERO COP GOES HOME.
The Bulletin’s headlines were almost as intriguing:
FORMER COP REPRIMANDED and FORMER COP TAKES IST PRIZE AT BIG E ARTS FESTIVAL.
“Come on up,” he said, putting his paper down. “Hard to believe all this is coming back. And then some.”
I took the stairs two at a time and settled in next to him on one of Sunnyview’s green- and- white- striped gliders. “I appreciate your seeing me.” An attendant brought us a pitcher of iced tea and two glasses.
“Thanks, Genevieve. I love to watch her walk away,” he said to me, looking at her. “I don’t get many visitors. Except Tom Robbins, the kid from the recycling center. He brings me scrap metal for my sculptures and slips me the occasional Victoria’s Secret catalog for inspiration.”