"Looks like it."
"What kind of matches did you make?"
"A few times I thought I might have something, but then the little girl, Mary Beth, would throw it off."
Hallock nodded. "Know what you mean. Let's hear it anyway."
Colin picked up his second sheet and began to read. "Two of the victims have brown eyes, two blue. Two have blond hair, two brown." He looked up from the paper. "Of course, Ruth Cooper's was dyed. She'd already turned gray but she'd been a brunette." He continued reading. "Three of them were between five feet five and five feet eleven. Mary Beth threw that one off. The weight didn't seem to mean anything," he said.
"Keep going. You're doing fine."
"Two were married, one engaged. Three were born in Seaville, one in Mattituck. They all had siblings. They all had living parents. Two had children. One was a housewife, two had jobs. Two lived in Seaville, one in Bay View, one in East Hampton. Three had a two in their address, three had fives, and three had zeros. Two had moderate incomes, one a combined income of over eighty thousand, and one none." Colin put down the paper. "I think the only significant thing is that they were all born in the North Fork. Natives."
"What's significant about that?"
"I shouldn't have said significant, that's too strong. What I mean is, it's the only common denominator."
"I agree." He held out his piece of paper, tapped the line where he'd discovered the same thing.
"So what's it mean?" Colin asked.
"I'm not sure. I just know there isn't anything else. Like you said, the only common denominator. I think we should check more on the families. Maybe it's something in the backgrounds. Grandparents, even."
"Okay. Higbee and Carroll's immediate families are here, but what about Cooper and Danowski?"
Hallock said, "Cooper's parents live in Florida. Miami Beach, I think. Got to look that up. Danowski's parents are in Bellport. If you can handle them, I can take the ones in Florida. What I mean is, I got more time on my hands than you. But you could probably take an afternoon to go down island to Bellport, couldn't you?"
Colin took a slug of coffee, stalling for time. "Couldn't I do it by phone?"
Hallock looked surprised. "An old newspaperman like you ought to know the personal touch always works best."
"Right." He felt nauseated; too much coffee.
"What's up, Maguire? You don't look so hot."
He knew he'd have to tell him. "Waldo, I don't mean to let you down but, I… I can't go to Bellport. Ever since my family was murdered… I get these panic attacks. I can't go too far from home."
"You mean like acrophobia?"
"Agoraphobia," he corrected gently. "Sort of. But obviously I can leave my house. I just can't go too far away, and not with anybody else in the car."
"No big deal," Hallock said. "You check into Higbee and Carroll, I'll do the other two."
"Thanks."
Hallock waved his hand in dismissal. "Look, we all got problems. Anyway, sooner you can get on to those, the better."
"You really going to Florida?"
"Why the hell not?"
"When?"
"Tomorrow, maybe. I'll go down to Bellport today, see what I can find out about the…" He glanced down at his piece of crumpled paper. "… the Bennetts. Ethel and George. Think you can do some of this today?"
"Sure." He'd hoped to see Annie later, but that was tonight.
"Okay. You going to tell Griffing you're working on this with me?"
"I don't see why I should."
"Good."
Colin walked with him to the front porch. "But I don't think Mark would care."
Hallock started to say something then changed his mind.
"What?"
"Nothing."
"Come on, Waldo, that sucks."
"It'd just be better if you didn't say anything to anybody. About us working on this thing."
"Especially Mark?"
"No. Just anybody." He pushed open the screen door.
Colin thought Hallock was lying. "Okay, I'll keep it quiet."
Hallock said, "You get any leads today try me later at the motel. Room one-thirty-one."
Colin watched Hallock drive away. Some kids were coming down the street, wearing bathing suits and carrying a rubber raft. It was a beautiful day, seventy-five degrees, but Colin knew the water in the bay would still be cold. Kids never minded how cold the water was. He remembered how he and Brian would stay in the water for hours, fingertips shriveling, bodies almost blue, and still they wouldn't come out until their father or mother threatened punishment. For a moment Colin longed to be a boy again, free from problems. It was hard to believe there'd ever been such a time in his life. The last years had cast such a pall over everything he sometimes felt life had always been dark and dreary. But now there was Annie, a bright spot in an otherwise dim existence.
Back in the kitchen he lifted the phone and dialed her number, surprised as he realized he'd committed it to memory.
– -
Annie's phone rang.
He said, "Don't answer that."
She was shaking from anger and fear. The phone continued to ring and she looked toward the kitchen. "I want to answer my phone."
"No," he said, rising from the gray velvet couch and crossing the room in three long strides. Steve Cornwell towered over her, his face of oversize features like a caricature, the black hair neatly trimmed. He wore a green cotton jacket, blue polo shirt, plaid slacks with a white belt, and white loafers. "I don't want you to answer the phone because I'm here to talk. Get it?"
She nodded and backed away from him.
"Good. Sit down." He pointed to the rocking chair. She sat while he remained standing. "Why don't you give up the ghost, Mrs. Winters."
She tried to remain cool, her voice even. "It's not Mrs. Winters. As I've told you many times, it's Reverend Winters or Annie. Winters is my maiden name. What is it you want?"
The phone stopped ringing.
She looked toward the kitchen, futilely trying to will her caller to come to the house.
"Are you divorced?" he asked, ignoring her question.
"You know I'm not. My husband died. I asked you what you wanted. If you don't tell me or get out of here, I'm going to call the police."
He gave a short hoot of laughter. "So why don't you use your dead husband's name? It seems unfaithful to change it just because the poor guy's dead. You should have mentioned that in your sermon." He laughed again, showing large teeth like a mouthful of shells. "Funny you should pick fidelity for your sermon today."
Annie felt a sharp stab of guilt. "Steve," she said, trying to sound reasonable, "what's this all about?"
"I think you know."
"I don't know."
"I think you do," he insisted. "I've got my eye on you, Miss Winters. All the time." Cornwell pulled a pack of cigarettes from his pocket, tapped one out, and returned the pack.
"I don't like people smoking in my house."
"Don't you? That's too damn bad." He lit the cigarette, blew out the match, and dropped it on the rug.
Furious, Annie started to get up.
"Stay where you are," he commanded, eyes like two bullet holes.
"I want to get you an ashtray."
"Sit down," he ordered.
What if he's the killer? she thought. What if this is it? She knew she wasn't ready. Softly, she asked, "Just what do you want?"
"I want you out. I want you back in the kitchen where you belong."
"You're incredible." Was this really why he was here? she wondered. Was that all?
Cornwell tapped the cigarette with a long finger; ash fell to the rug.
Trying not to react, she looked at her watch. "I'm expected at dinner and I'm already late."
He went on as if she hadn't spoken. "I've put up with you as minister week after week, listened to your trite sermons, watched the others fawning over you, but now I've had it."
"I don't understand."
He smiled. "I'm going to get rid of you.
Her heart slammed in her chest.
"I might as well tell you I saw you with that reporter last night."