"Ralph," he said in a flat, cold tone. "I asked for black."
"Oh yeah?" Ralph shrugged. "You want something done right, do it yourself."
"You scheiskopf! " And suddenly Dennis Hamilton was gone, and the Emperor stood there in his place, an Emperor who had been pushed past all endurance and would brook no more. "It was your mistake." Dennis thrust the cup into the man's chest, so that the light, sticky brew splashed Pritchard's shirt, and husked out one word – "Black." The theatre grew deadly quiet, and no one moved for a long time.
~* ~
"I never," Dennis said to Ann, "never would have done that if you hadn't suggested it. And even then it was hard. I mean, Jesus, what a smartass punk, they must have thought."
"But he brought you a black coffee, didn't he?"
"Yes he did. I guess it helped that he was such a screwup to begin with. I don't know, maybe he thought I could actually get him replaced or something. After all, I was the star, whether I realized it or not."
"And you finally began to act like it."
"That's right. And I've been acting that way ever since. So following your advice not only made my reputation," said Dennis with a wry smile, "it ruined it as well. From enfant terrible to aging tyrant."
"Oh, the gratitude you must feel toward me. But you're not aging, you're forty-three, the same as…” She hesitated.
"The same as you. I know. No secrets here. But the years have been far kinder to you, Ann, than to me."
"How can you say that? You look wonderful."
"There are silver threads among the red, and, though you can't see it, I'm beginning to cultivate a paunch. The weight's remained the same, it's just been… redistributed." They laughed together, stopping only when the waiter refilled their wine glasses.
"So," Dennis said, "did you ask your daughter whether she'd be interested in working for us too?"
"No," Ann replied, and Dennis thought he saw a cloud pass over her face. "She wasn't home when I got there. Probably out with friends. I'll talk with her…” She paused, as if contemplating what the evening would hold. “… tonight, when I get home."
Dennis nodded. The mention of Ann's daughter had unexpectedly introduced the spectre of all the years that had passed since the nights they had last sat here, at first holding hands, later kissing with light, gentle kisses when the waiters' and other diners' attentions were elsewhere.
They did not hold hands now, though Dennis wanted to. From the moment he had seen Aim that day, he knew that his feelings for her had never left, that although at times he had denied her existence, he knew now that he had done so to spare himself the pain of life without her. For only by not thinking about her, by banishing her from his mind, could he live with the knowledge that he loved her, and always would.
He looked at her now, and her gaze came up and met his, their eyes held, and they both knew the secret the other was trying to hide. He saw tears in her eyes and felt them form in his own, tears of self-pity for all the years spent apart, for the life they might have had together.
Her hand touched his, her cool fingers intertwined with his own. There were no words. They only sat and watched one another, as if trying to drink in the sight, quench the thirst of a quarter century, attempt to fill that emotional reservoir they both knew was bottomless, infinite, in preparation for an uncertain future.
"Oh, Ann," he whispered, his throat thick with grief and joy. "I'm sorry. I'm so sorry." Sorry for what had been, he wondered, or sorry for what was yet to come?
"No," she said, looking away at last, brushing away the tears with the hand that was not holding his. "I'm the one who's sorry. Sorry for what happened, sorry I came back to see you…”
"No. Don't be sorry for that, don't ever be. I'm glad you came."
"I shouldn't have. I shouldn't take the job, I should just go home and forget all about this, about you…”
" No." His hand tightened on hers. "I don't want you to do that. Please stay." She shook her head as though it weighed a ton. "You're married. I don't want to… to be the cause of anything."
"You won't," he said, thinking that it was a lie, saying it nonetheless, thinking that he would have said anything to be with her longer. And then he thought that maybe what he said was true, but that he didn't want it to be.
At last she took her hand away, and his own hand had never felt so empty. "I don't know why," she said with a crooked smile, "why you have stayed in my mind all these years."
Dennis felt her smile mirrored on his own face. "Maybe it's because we loved each other, but we were never lovers. That's… a reflection, not a proposition."
"And taken as such." She sighed, sat back in her chair, and took a sip of wine. "You may be right, though. It was… relatively chaste. So all these years I suppose I've thought about what it would have been like." Now the smile held true humor. "And probably the fantasy is better than the reality."
"It generally is," Dennis said. "But there are exceptions to that rule." Ann's face became sad again. "We'll never know, will we?"
"No," Dennis said. "I guess we won't."
They sat there silently until Ann spoke again. "What if I asked you?" she said. "I'm not, but what if I did? What if I asked you to take me back with you tonight? What would you say?"
I've been an actor too long, Dennis thought, and acted again. "I'd say no. For both of us."
"And for your wife."
"And for my wife, yes." Then he added, as though it needed to be said. "I love her, Ann."
He walked her to her car. They did not hold hands, nor did they embrace when she got in. "I start Thursday," she said.
"Good," he said. "Good. Have Terri come with you and meet Marvella, yes?"
"All right." He closed the door for her, but she opened the window and spoke to him through it. "Dennis, if this doesn't work, don't blame me if I quit. Right now I just want to see you, even if I can't
… be with you. Maybe it'll pass. I hope it will."
"I know. I know how you feel. I feel the same way."
She smiled. "This has got doom written all over it, hasn't it?"
"Yes."
"Are we stupid?"
"Maybe. But we don't have to be." And he thought yes, yes, we are stupid. And we are helpless as well. But he only said, "Goodnight, Ann."
He turned then and walked down the street, not looking back, fearful that if he did he would go back to her, and though his heart wanted him to, his mind did not. He reminded himself that he loved his wife, he loved Robin, and he would not, could not be unfaithful to her. He had played that game too many times before with other women he had pretended to love. He would not do it to Robin, not to Robin. He owed her more than that.
When he returned to his suite, it seemed more empty than ever. He wished that Robin were there, and, out of loneliness and the desire to hear her voice, called her at the apartment they kept in New York. She sounded the same as ever, and told him that one show in particular stood out among the several finalists she had reviewed, and that she would be returning on Friday with the script and a tape of the music. He told her that he missed her and loved her, and she sounded, he thought, surprised to hear it.
She also sounded, he was dismayed to learn, ever so slightly like a stranger.
~* ~
What if he had given a different answer, Ann wondered as she drove home. What if he had said yes, I'd take you back with me, and I'd make love to you for the first time, and it would be the first time for the both of us for the rest of our lives, and we would spend the rest of our lives together, no one else, the way it should have been so many years ago.
What would I have done? Would I have gone with him if he had asked me to? God, I don't know. I would have wanted to, but would I have gone?