Katelynn interrupted him before he could go any further in his explanation. “Wait a minute!” she said sharply, her mild irritation at Sam’s question having rapidly grown into annoyance with Gabriel’s response to it. “Are you trying to tell us that Sebastian Blake practiced witchcraft?”
“Dark Magic might be a more appropriate term for it, but yes, that is what I am telling you,” he answered simply, the congenial expression never leaving his face.
“Cool!” Sam exclaimed happily. When he’d agreed to bring Katelynn in to see Gabriel, he’d expected to sit through a long conversation about a guy who’d long since turned to dust and who’d led a life so boring that no one even remembered him. Now all of a sudden they were talking about something that was right up his alley—a real, live warlock, right in his own town!
Katelynn, however, was far from thrilled at the news. “I’m sorry, but I just can’t believe that,” she said.
“Why not?” Gabriel asked, a playful smile on his lips and a twinkle in his eye.
His expression just served to aggravate Katelynn further. He was a nice old man, and probably pretty lonely most of the time. That was why he liked making up stories to tell Sam while Sam worked the late shift, only the two of them awake so late at night. He’d probably misunderstood how serious she was, and having no real information that could help, had decided to invent some story along the lines of the ones he told Sam, thinking that was what she wanted to hear. She’d come looking for solid leads to help her, and talk of rituals and black magic was just going to put her in a foul mood. How gullible did he think she was?
“Why don’t I believe it?” she answered him, the smile on her face as false as a three-dollar bill. “I’ll tell you why I don’t believe it. Because there is no such thing as black magic.”
“Are you so sure of that, Katelynn? Has someone actually proven that such a thing does not exist?”
“Of course not. No reputable scientist would bother with such an experiment. The idea of magic completely defies what we know of modern physics. It just can’t happen.”
“Ahh, but remember what we are talking about here. We’re not discussing modern ideas of reality but the views of those people who created this town in the late 1600s. Belief in witchcraft was a way of life back then, and in just about every small town you could find some man or woman who was considered a witch or warlock. Having those individuals run out of town or put to death by angry mobs in the middle of the night was not uncommon, especially here in the backwoods of New England. Just look at Salem. Do you really think these people didn’t believe in magic?”
Grudgingly, Katelynn had to admit that he was right. When delving into the past, one had to remember that modern beliefs and attitudes just didn’t belong. You had to adopt the beliefs of that particular era, or you would arrive at incorrect conclusions, just as she was doing now.But what did all this have to do with Blake?
Gabriel was more than happy to let her know. “Blake believed that he could gain power through the use of black magic, and much of his public demeanor was just an act, designed to deceive the townspeople into accepting him back into the fold while his research went on behind their backs. He scoured every reference he could find, tome after tome after tome, searching for just the right ritual that would put him in touch with the dark entities he believed existed amongst us, hoping to make use of their power to elevate himself into a position of dominance in the community.”
“Then, in the early months of 1762, the killings began. The townspeople at first thought they were accidents, for they had been cleverly disguised as such. A wagon accident here, a sudden fall from a horse there, a child lost in the woods and found frozen to death the next day. But as the year passed, the killings became more frequent. And more violent. Random accidents could no longer account for what was happening, and the ravaged conditions of the corpses made the people begin to suspect that something out of the ordinary was going on. Then, late in 1763, the killer was discovered.”
Katelynn was listening with a skeptical look on her face, but Sam was completely engrossed in Gabriel’s tale, his belief in every word etched clearly on his face.
“An anonymous tip sent the local authorities to a small shack on the woods of the Blake family estate, and there they discovered Sebastian in the midst of one of his foul rituals. A small child was laid out on an altar before him as some kind of sacrifice to the powers with whom he had fallen in league. Before their very eyes, he plunged a knife into the young one’s chest and cut out his living heart.”
The old man shuddered, and Katelynn found herself involuntarily responding in kind. One thing she had to give him credit for; Gabriel was a great storyteller. Whether what he had to say had any basis in fact was another issue altogether.
“The townsfolk saw no need to wait for a formal trial. They formed a lynch mob and hanged him on the spot.”
“So how come there is no record of any of this?” Katelynn asked, trying to trip the man up.
He had an answer ready for that as well. “Not wanting to besmirch the Blake family name, or to create a reputation for their newly prospering town, the village elders agreed to wipe any reference of the event from the records and forbade the papers from printing anything concerning the story, which wasn’t difficult because they were owned by the Blakes.”
“So how am I going to prove that this actually occurred?” she asked him.
Gabriel sat back and spread his hands, palms up. “I don’t know. You’re going to have to figure that one out for yourself. I’ve told you all that I know.”
Throughout the story Sam had been quiet, but he finally spoke. “They couldn’t have gotten to everyone, Katelynn. There’s bound to be someone who recorded the events. A merchant, or a traveling minister, maybe even one of the families of the victims. At the very least you should be able to document the number of deaths that occurred at that time, right?”
Katelynn thought about it for a moment, then agreed. The town records, if they were still around, should show the death certificates for those years. If she could substantiate the deaths, she might be able to find another lead to help her prove the rest. She smiled to herself, surprised that she was seriously considering the story she’d just heard. The idea that Blake was consorting with the Devil was absurd, but proving the man had been some kind of a serial killer was not beyond her ability.
She focused her attention back on Gabriel. “Could you tell me any more about the people who were murdered?” she asked hopefully.
The well of information that Gabriel seemed to possess had apparently run dry. He didn’t know the names of any of the victims, or the dates on which they had been killed. Nothing except for the fact that it had started in early 1762 and ended in late 1763. “I’m sorry I can’t help you more,” he said.
“Oh, that’s okay. You’ve given me a beginning, anyway. I’m not saying I believe it, but maybe it’s worth looking into.”
He smiled at her, and she gave him one of her own, the skepticism she’d felt earlier in the conversation having dissipated.
They chatted for a few minutes more, then said their good-byes. Sam had to start his shift, and Katelynn had to prepare a lesson for the class she was teaching in the morning. They told Gabriel they’d be back to see him soon and stepped out into the hallway.
“What do you think, Katelynn?” Sam asked, as they headed for the nursing station at the other end of the hall where he was assigned for the duration of his shift. “Do you think he was telling the truth?”