Tyler watched this, then snatched the bottle out of her hands. He took a long drink and finished it off. “Jesus,” he muttered. “You are sixteen.”
“Seventeen,” she whispered.
He closed his eyes and banged his head back against the chair. Several times.
“Trying to get the blood flow back to the head that matters?” she said.
“Trying to figure out if I’m committing a felony.”
“You’re not. How old are you?”
“Twenty-one.”
“Four years. We could have been in high school together.” That seemed to settle him. “So you’re a senior?”
“Junior. And what, you’re a junior in college? It’s totally like the same thing.”
That made him smile.
“Is this more of your freaky honor code?” she said. “Murdering an innocent family is okay, but a slight gap in age—”
“They’re not innocent,” Tyler snapped.
“Quick, bang your other head against the chair. Too much thinking is going on.”
Tyler sighed. He put his hands on her waist, almost a caress. But then he tightened his grip as if he was going to set her on her feet.
“Wait,” Quinn said, putting her hands over his. “Don’t stop it. Please.”
“Why?”
A genuine question. So she gave him a genuine answer. “Because I like you,” she said.
His thumbs stroked over her abdomen. “I like you, too.”
“Maybe we should go back to Little League,” she said.
“What?”
“Or at least the minors.”
His eyebrows went up. “Are you telling me to slow down?”
“Not for my benefit. For yours, old man.”
Now he definitely looked like he was going to put her on her feet. So she rotated in his hands to sit against him again. She pressed her face into his neck. “Sing me another song?”
He hesitated just long enough that she thought he’d refuse.
But then he picked up the guitar, set it across her lap, and started to play.
CHAPTER 16
While he slept, Nick forgot about the lunch table argument with his brothers. Or rather, his brother. Maybe it was Quinn’s drama, maybe it was the peace and quiet of Adam’s apartment, but creepy didn’t come crashing back into his brain until Gabriel opened the bathroom door the next morning, while Nick was brushing his teeth.
Every muscle in his body tensed. He wanted to shove Gabriel back out and slam the door in his face.
Instead, he spit toothpaste into the sink and wiped his mouth without looking at him.
“What is up with you?” said Gabriel.
“Nothing is up with me.” Nick moved to edge past him.
Gabriel caught him around the neck and roughed up his hair. “I know how to make you talk, Nicky.”
The motion was good-natured, the kind of thing that would usually make him laugh.
But Nick twisted free and shoved Gabriel into the wall so hard it rattled the towel rack. He pinned him there and forced his voice to stay low. “Leave me alone. Okay?”
Gabriel stared at him, identical blue eyes searching his. He could have fought back, but he didn’t. “Sure, Nick. Whatever you want.”
Whatever you want. Yeah, right.
Nick let him go and stepped into the hallway, jerking the door shut behind him. His throat felt tight, and he had no idea what expression was on his face, but it must not have been good. Chris stood there in the hallway, and when Nick met his eyes, Chris put his hands up and took a step back.
Damn it. He couldn’t find the right rhythm with anyone lately.
Nick went into his bedroom and closed the door. Hunter was already downstairs, his air mattress made like a military bunk. Nick sat on the edge of his bed and put his head in his hands.
Part of him wished Gabriel had fought back, had pushed and needled and forced the truth out of him.
Part of him wanted to go back in the bathroom and punch his twin brother.
A knock sounded at his door.
Nick stared at the six-foot panel of wood and wondered if fate was going to deliver those options on a silver platter.
Then the door cracked open, just enough to let his younger brother peek through. “It’s Chris.” A pause. “Can I come in?”
Nick sighed. “Sure.”
Chris opened the door, but he didn’t come inside. He leaned against the doorjamb and looked hesitant. “I don’t want to get in the middle of something, here.”
Please. Pry. Tell me you’ve figured everything out.
“It’s fine,” Nick said. It wasn’t even seven a.m. and he was already exhausted. “What’s up?”
“Are you and Quinn all right?”
Nick let out a frustrated breath. “Why does everyone keep asking me that?”
“Because you look like you want to kill someone, and that’s usually Michael’s gig.”
“I don’t want to kill anyone.”
Except Tyler. And maybe Gabriel.
Chris came all the way into the room and dropped onto the side of the bed. “Becca told me to ask if you guys wanted to come over to her place tonight. We’re going to get a pizza, rent a movie. Hang out.” He waggled his eyebrows. “Et cetera.”
There was a time when Nick would have jumped at the chance, just to force other things out of his brain. And, he admitted to himself, to keep up appearances. He and Gabriel used to take girls out together, just because they could. But since he and Chris had been dating Quinn and Becca, they’d done the double date thing a few times.
Now, however, he was glad to have a reason to refuse. “I can’t. I told Mike I would babysit.”
Chris smiled. “Sucker. I knew you’d say yes.”
Of course he did. Nick always did what his brothers needed.
Maybe Chris read his darkening mood, because he lost the smile before Nick could say anything. “Well, I said I would ask.” He paused and looked at the wall like something interesting was happening there. He didn’t say anything for a long time, but the air felt heavy, and Nick waited. Chris wasn’t a talker, and when he had something to say, it took him a while to get around to it.
When he finally spoke, his voice was low. “If something is going on, you can tell me. I know you always tell Gabriel everything, but—I’ll keep your secret, too.”
Nick looked at him. He didn’t know what to say.
When Becca’s father had come to town to kill them all, he’d trapped Chris and Nick in a walk-in freezer. Nick’s leg had been broken, and he’d barely been able to move. Just another instance where he wasn’t strong enough to save anyone. Michael and Gabriel had rescued them.
For the first time, Nick realized that Chris hadn’t been able to save himself, either. And Chris might have been a year younger, but he sure as hell wasn’t weak.
Nick had been quiet too long. Chris finally turned away from the wall and met his eyes.
There were too many variables here. Nick worried the tension in his body might rattle it to pieces.
His cell phone buzzed on his nightstand. Nick jumped. He could see the screen lit up with a text message, but he couldn’t see the sender.
Chris was closer. If he looked over, he’d see it.
He didn’t look.
Nick ran a hand through his hair, putting some order to the mess Gabriel had made. “I need to finish getting ready for school.”
Chris nodded. “Me, too.” He hesitated in the doorway. “If you see Quinn, please tell her Becca’s really worried about her. She’s not responding to her texts or anything.”
Join the club. But at least Nick could offer an explanation for this. “I told Quinn the truth. About us. I think she’s upset that she didn’t learn about it from Becca.”