Finn’s mouth came open. “You’re a sadistic bastard.”
Julian shrugged. “I thought that was obvious. Do I need to wear a button? Or one of those Hello, My Name is… badges?”
Dani frowned and turned her head back. Was Finn ready to bolt? Her arousal dimmed as she felt the weight of Finn’s stare on her backside. Maybe this was a bad idea. What Julian made seem normal and almost loving was counter to everything she’d been taught. Nice girls didn’t accept anal plugs and call their lovers Sir.
Julian walked straight up to Finn and sank his fingers into Finn’s thick, dark hair. He pushed Finn to his knees, a completely feral expression on his face. “Do you have any idea what you just did to her? You prissy little fuck. She was perfectly happy until you set your ridiculous morality on her. There is no right or wrong in this room. There is only what works. You think she can’t handle your sexuality? You’re the one who has a problem with it, Finn. Tell me something. Why is your cock hard, Finn? I see it straining against the fly of your jeans. Is it hard because you want to spank her sweet ass?”
Dani watched as Finn swallowed once and then again. He didn’t fight Julian’s hold. He was on his knees with Julian above him. They made a gorgeous picture.
“No. That’s not it, Sir.”
“Then what is making you hard, Finn? I suspect it’s not the idea of disciplining Danielle. I suspect you want to be disciplined yourself.”
Finn’s head nodded, though there was almost shame in the gesture.
Julian let Finn’s head fall forward. He sighed. “You’re not ready. Go. I won’t have you infecting Danielle with your ideals. She is more open and accepting of her nature than you are. You are the problem here, not Danielle.” He turned to her. “Who is not in the position I left her.”
Dani turned quickly and got back into position. The plug filled her ass and jangled against her nerves every time she moved.
“I don’t want to go,” Finn stated, his voice sounding small. “I…want this. I just…it’s hard. I want so many things that place me on the outside. I’m always on the fucking outside.”
Julian sighed. “You are only on the outside because you’re trying to fit into your idea of the normal world. The world is what you make it, Finn. There are as many worlds as there are people. This is your world. You are the only one who can force yourself out of it. Now, Danielle and I would like to play. If you can properly submit, you are welcome to stay. I suggest you take your clothes off and join Danielle. I can get all of the discipline out of the way, and we can move on to the portion of the night where we take care of each other in more pleasurable ways.”
Dani waited, breath held in, as Finn slowly stood. He stared at her. She could see the longing in his eyes. He slanted a glance at Julian, as well. That was pure lust. She couldn’t miss that. Finn seemed to reach some decision, and his hands quickly tackled the fly of his jeans. Dani watched as they hit the floor. No underwear for Finn, just a really big, really hard cock. Holy cow. He was gorgeous. Finn was naked, and there was no hiding how beautiful he was. Broad shoulders led to a tapered waist and washboard abs. He was chiseled to perfection.
“Stop.” Julian issued the order, and Finn stopped on command.
As he had with her, Julian carefully inspected Finn. He ran his hands along Finn’s skin, no expression on his face. He traced a line from Finn’s chin all the way down, through the valley of his chest, past his navel, all the way down to his cock. Julian took that hard cock in his hand, stroking, pumping. Finn’s eyes closed, but not before Dani saw the pleasure there.
“You’ll do nicely, Finn. Now, take your place beside Danielle. Ass in the air.”
There was no hesitation this time. Finn jumped to do Julian’s bidding. He was beside her in a heartbeat. His hand brushed against hers. Their eyes met.
“I love you, Dani.”
He whispered the words. Dani let their pinky fingers tangle together.
“I have a plug up my ass,” Dani whispered with a grin. “What’s he gonna shove up yours?”
The tense look on Finn’s face disappeared, and a wide grin took its place. “I have a feeling it’s going to be bigger than your plug.”
“No talking. I normally don’t do this, but the two of you look very sweet together. Finn, I don’t have another plug handy, though I doubt you need one. Is your ass used to taking a pounding?”
Finn flushed, but Dani winked at him. “Yes, Sir. I’m more than ready for you, Sir.”
“Excellent. Ten swats apiece. No talking unless I give you express permission, is that understood? No count is required this evening.”
Dani nodded at the man in the mirror. He’d taken his shirt off and stood behind them in nothing but his slacks. His long, dark hair had come out of its queue and fell around his shoulders. He pulled back the paddle.
Thwack. The sound rang through the small room. Dani hissed at the pain that spread across her ass. The plug lit up every nerve in her rectum, making her eyes water with a weird sort of jagged pleasure. There was no mistaking the bite of pain, but she felt her muscles clench around the plug, desperate to keep it in.
Finn’s fingers wound around hers as Julian continued the torture. He smacked her ass over and over. The wide paddle was different than his hand. He struck hard and fast. Unlike her previous spanking, he concentrated on her ass. There was no moving, just the quick strike of hard paddle against soft flesh.
It hurt. There was no doubt about that. Dani cried. Tears flowed down her face, but all the while her pussy was throbbing. Her breasts dangled, jiggling with each and every swat. By the time Julian brought the paddle down for the last time, a nice floaty feeling had started to take the place of the hot pain.
His hand caressed the cheeks of her ass, and a single finger found its way to her weeping cunt.
“Yes, little one, that’s what we both want. Do you have any idea how much this pleases me? You’re ripe and ready for me, but it has to wait. Kneel down on the bed and watch Finn’s punishment. Don’t lose that plug, Danielle. I’ll find something bigger if you do.”
Dani moved gingerly to follow his directions. Her ass was still on fire, and now her pussy ached. She wanted to beg Julian to take her, but she was curious. She wanted to watch them together. She knelt on the bed, careful to clench her ass cheeks together.
“Do you understand why I’m punishing you, Finn?”
“Sort of. I shouldn’t have started that fight. Dani could have gotten hurt.”
“You could have gotten hurt, too, Finn. It is my responsibility to keep you safe. That is part of the reason. The other part is that it’s my responsibility to give you what you need. I believe you need this.”
Julian’s hand reared back, and the paddle struck Finn’s muscled ass with vicious force. Dani gasped as Finn groaned, and his head fell forward. Julian struck again and again. This couldn’t be what he’d done to her. Her ass was still sore, but Finn’s was bright red. Dani could see tears dripping from his eyes, and his bottom lip was between his teeth. His guttural groans filled the room as Julian beat his ass over and over again. When it was finally over, Finn slumped forward. He would have hit the floor had Julian not caught him, his big arms going around Finn’s middle.
Dani held her breath.
Finn’s eyes opened, and a slightly loopy grin crossed his face.
“Did you come, sub?” Julian’s gaze was fast on Finn’s cock.
“No, Sir, but it was a close thing.”
“That was good, Finn. For a beginner. Lie down, face-first. I’ll treat you to some aftercare.”
Finn stretched out beside her and sighed. “I think I’m going to like aftercare, Dani.”