“Um. But, Saxon…Saxon told me about this paper. Was it just, like, an assignment or something?” Cadence’s mouth pressed in a flat, tight line.
I couldn’t believe Saxon had already told her about it. I wondered how much he told her. And why. And if he’d regret it.
“Yeah. Kind of.” A wave of irrational anger washed over me. “She was supposed to write about something she felt passionate about.
“Oh. Passion? But she and Saxon dated in the past. It’s all done now, right? And they’re just friends?” Cadence looked at me like I might have the answer, not realizing that was the same damn question drumming through my head.
I dug deep into my gut for the answer, and said what I honestly believed was true. “Brenna doesn’t make a hell of a lot of sense to me sometimes,” I admitted. “She likes to think about things. A lot. But she said they were done a while ago, and I don’t have any reason to doubt her. She’s loyal and honest, and I believe her.” And I did. Relief skipped through me like a stone on a flat lake.
Cadence reached her hand across the table and squeezed mine. “Cool. I’m glad we got to talk a little. Maybe we could all go out sometime?”
“Sure. Yeah. That would be cool.” God, she was pretty. She had this silky brown-black hair that shined and nice lips, the kind that looked like they would be good for kissing.
She let go of my hand and it was like my head righted itself again.
What the hell was I thinking?
This was Saxon’s girlfriend. Didn’t I have enough trouble with Brenna? Wasn’t I just damning Saxon for exactly what I was feeling? I looked at Cadence, who didn’t look away from me at all.
I liked the way she looked. I liked her confidence and the fact that she was sweet and smart and honest. If Saxon had met her a year before, before I had known Brenna, would I have wanted to steal her away?
“I can see Brenna’s theoretical problem, you know,” she said and smiled. Great smile. Nice teeth, a little dimple on the left side.
“What’s that?” I shook the thoughts about her smile out of my head.
“Well, a lot of guys are just losers. And then there’s you and your brother. You’re kind of overwhelming, you know? Really good-looking, kind of bad-ass, kind of sweet, just really attractive. And there’re two of you. I just can see how she might have got caught up in…you two.” She tucked her hair behind her ear self-consciously.
I opened my mouth to say the next thing that I was going to say, which, honestly, probably would have been pseudo-flirting, when Saxon came back in. Luckily, he was too focused on his iPod to notice that Cadence and I backed up quickly and looked sheepish. Not that there was anything to look sheepish about.
“This is Folly. I think it’s their best, but you’ll have to listen and see what you think.” He put one earbud in Cadence’s ear and offered the other one to me.
I had to move around the table so that I was sitting close to her. She smelled good. Her skin was dark, tanned, and it looked smooth and soft, the way girls’ skin always looked to me. We listened a few inches apart, and I was glad that we had a good excuse to keep quiet. Because I didn’t know what to say.
Cadence glanced over at me a few times and gave me that tiny smile, like she was hiding the second part of it so she could share it later. I liked her smile. I liked the look on her face. She would have been really easy to fall in love with.
If she wasn’t with Saxon. If I wasn’t with Brenna.
Just thinking it to myself, it sounded a little man-whorish. But the point wasn’t really that I wanted Cadence. It was that I had been kind of wrapped up in Brenna and there wasn’t anyone else I could imagine liking. But I knew that didn’t mean that I would never be attracted to anyone else. For me, it was easier because I had been with so many girls. Granted, none of them had been nearly as smart or cool or sweet as Brenna was. But I had my shot.
It was hard for me to put Brenna into perspective. The fact was, I had been lucky enough to be right there when she was first looking to date. There hadn’t been anyone before me, and she and I got serious fast. Brenna was a fairly independent girl. That couldn’t have sat very well with her.
By the end of the song, I felt at peace, but also shaken up. Knowing things, or realizing them, didn’t necessarily make them easier to deal with. Not for me. I could understand being attracted to someone else, and wanting the freedom to be with other people.
But I loved Brenna. And what I really wanted was for her to write an essay about how much I rocked her world. Maybe it was selfish, but it was also honest. I couldn’t hate her for what she wrote, but it made me kind of pissed off that she divided her love up like that. All I had was her. And I loved her with my whole heart.
We played a few more hands of Palace, but Cadence had a curfew and Saxon seemed pretty serious about sticking to it. By the time he got back home, I had dragged the old musty cot out and was almost asleep.
He fell onto the mattress with a noisy squeak of the springs. “You asleep, Jake?”
“No.”
“I’m sorry about this whole thing,” he said awkwardly.
I was glad that it was dark and we couldn’t see each other. “Why would you be sorry? Brenna wrote it.”
“Because I shouldn’t have butted in with her when I did. I just didn’t know what the hell I was doing.” The silence stretched out for a long minute. “Jake?”
“I hear you,” I said into the dark.
“Now that Cadence and I are together, I just…uh, I realize what I was doing.” I’d never heard Saxon stammer for words unless he was hard-core hammered. I knew he was stone sober. “And it’s, well, it’s fucked up. I was fucked up. I’m glad you knocked my tooth out. I deserved it. I deserved more.”
It was getting unusually sappy between us. Plus that, I hated being the recipient of any of Saxon’s pity, so I smashed back at him with the biggest, nastiest weapon in my arsenal. “If I wasn’t with Bren, I’d steal Cadence out from under you in a fucking hot second.”
I heard Saxon pull in a sharp breath. “Dude, I’m going to kick your fucking ass.”
“Do it.” I lay still on my uncomfortable-as-all-hell cot.
It was tense and quiet for a minute. Then Saxon laughed. I couldn’t help it; I laughed too. Because it was so ridiculous and stupid, it was funny.
“Go to sleep, you fucking asshole,” Saxon said good-naturedly. “And tomorrow, go see Brenna. Maybe you can get some make-up sex out of this whole clusterfuck.”
Which was probably not the best last thought before I tried to relax and fall asleep, but there were definitely worse endings to a day like the one I had. Brenna was tangled in my dreams, and so was make-up sex.
The next morning Saxon was still asleep when I got up. I went out to the kitchen and Aunt Helene was already awake with waffles and bacon for me. She clucked around and made a big deal out of making sure I ate what I was supposed to. She also had the picture album for me.
“You know, Jake,” she said when she handed it to me, “you’re very young. Just enjoy who you are and what you have now. There will be so much coming to you. Don’t be so worried all the time.” She patted my arm.
I got up and hugged her. “Thanks,” I said, and I meant it. And I hoped she understood all I meant when I said it; thanks for food, thanks for memories, thanks for giving a shit.
I got in my truck and roared away, driving a little too fast. The air was still cool since it was a while before sunup. Brenna might not even be awake, but I needed to see her.
I parked down the street, the opposite side that her mother used to drive to work. I went to her window, open like it always was since she liked to sleep in the fresh air, and sat under it for a while, not sure what I wanted to say when I saw her. There was probably no worse idea. By the time five minutes had gone by, I was so chicken-shit I could hardly think about going in.
So I turned my brain off, stopped thinking, and just went ahead and did what I needed to do.