Nevertheless he remained in a nervous state, and did not return home until nearly noon. When on his arrival he found Leigh, the occultist, waiting, he was glad to see the man, and invited him in with cordiality.
Leigh was very serious. “Did you hear about your friend Abigail Prinn?” he asked without preamble, and Carson stared, pausing in the act of siphoning charged water into a glass. After a long moment he pressed the lever, sent the liquid sizzling and foaming into the whiskey. He handed Leigh the drink and took one himself — neat — before answering the question.
“I don’t know what you’re talking about. Has — what’s she been up to?” he asked, with an air of forced levity.
“I’ve been checking up the records,” Leigh said, “and I find Abigail Prinn was buried on December 14th, 1690, in the Charter Street Burying Ground — with a stake through her heart. What’s the matter?”
“Nothing,” Carson said tonelessly. “Well?”
“Well — her grave’s been opened and robbed, that’s all. The stake was found uprooted nearby, and there were footprints all around the grave. Shoe-prints. Did you dream last night, Carson?” Leigh snapped out the question, his gray eyes hard.
“I don’t know,” Carson said confusedly, rubbing his forehead. “I can’t remember. I was at the Charter Street graveyard this morning.”
“Oh. Then you must have heard something about the man who—”
“I saw him,” Carson interrupted, shuddering. “It upset me.”
He downed the whiskey at a gulp.
Leigh watched him. “Well,” he said presently, “are you still determined to stay in this house?”
Carson put down the glass and stood up.
“Why not?” he snapped. “Is there any reason why I shouldn’t? Eh?”
“After what happened last night—”
“After what happened? A grave was robbed. A superstitious Pole saw the robbers and died of fright. Well?”
“You’re trying to convince yourself,” Leigh said calmly. “In your heart you know — you must know — the truth. You’ve become a tool in the hands of tremendous terrible forces, Carson. For three centuries Abbie Prinn has lain in her grave — undead — waiting for someone to fall into her trap — the Witch Room. Perhaps she foresaw the future when she built it, foresaw that someday someone would blunder into that hellish chamber and be caught by the trap of the mosaic pattern. It caught you, Carson — and enabled that undead horror to bridge the gulf between consciousness and matter, to get en rapport with you. Hypnotism is child’s play to a being with Abigail Prinn’s frightful powers. She could very easily force you to go to her grave and uproot the stake that held her captive, and then erase the memory of that act from your mind so that you could not remember it even as a dream!”
Carson was on his feet, his eyes burning with a strange light. “In God’s name, man, do you know what you’re saying?”
Leigh laughed harshly. “God’s name! The devil’s name, rather — the devil that menaces Salem at this moment; for Salem is in danger, terrible danger. The men and women and children of the town Abbie Prinn cursed when they bound her to the stake — and found they couldn’t burn her! I’ve been going through certain secret archives this morning, and I’ve come to ask you, for the last time, to leave this house.”
“Are you through?” Carson asked coldly. “Very well. I shall stay here. You’re either insane or drunk, but you can’t impress me with your poppycock.”
“Would you leave if I offered you a thousand dollars?” Leigh asked. “Or more, then — ten thousand? I have a considerable sum at my command.”
“No, damn it!” Carson snapped in a sudden blaze of anger. “All I want, is to be left alone to finish my novel. I can’t work anywhere else — I don’t want to, I won’t—”
“I expected this,” Leigh said, his voice suddenly quiet, and with a strange note of sympathy. “Man, you can’t get away! You’re caught in the trap, and it’s too late for you to extricate yourself so long as Abbie Prinn’s brain controls you through the Witch Room. And the worst part of it is that she can only manifest herself with your aid — she drains your life forces, Carson, feeds on you like a vampire.”
“You’re mad,” Carson said dully.
“I’m afraid. That iron disk in the Witch Room — I’m afraid of that, and what’s under it. Abbie Prinn served strange gods, Carson — and I read something on the wall of that alcove that gave me a hint. Have you ever heard of Nyogtha?”
Carson shook his head impatiently. Leigh fumbled in a pocket, drew out a scrap of paper. “I copied this from a book in the Kester Library,” he said, “a book called the Necronomicon, written by a man who delved so deeply into forbidden secrets that men called him mad. Read this.”
Carson’s brows drew together as he read the excerpt:
Men know him as the Dweller in Darkness, that brother of the Old Ones called Nyogtha, the Thing that should not be. He can be summoned to Earth’s surface through certain secret caverns and fissures, and sorcerers have seen him in Syria and below the black tower of Leng; from the Thang Grotto of Tartary he has come ravening to bring terror and destruction among the pavilions of the great Khan. Only by the looped cross, by the Vach-Viraj incantation, and by the Tikkoun elixir may he be driven back to the nighted caverns of hidden foulness where he dwelleth.
Leigh met Carson’s puzzled gaze calmly. “Do you understand now?”
“Incantations and elixirs!” Carson said, handing back the paper. “Fiddlesticks!”
“Far from it. That incantation and that elixir have been known to occultists and adepts for thousands of years. I’ve had occasion to use them myself in the past on certain — occasions. And if I’m right about this thing—” He turned to the door, his lips compressed in a bloodless line. “Such manifestations have been defeated before, but the difficulty lies in obtaining the elixir — it’s very hard to get. But I hope…. I’ll be back. Can you stay out of the Witch Room until then?”
“I’ll promise nothing,” Carson said. He had a dull headache, which had been steadily growing until it obtruded upon his consciousness, and he felt vaguely nauseated. “Good-bye.”
He saw Leigh to the door and waited on the steps, with an odd reluctance to return to the house. As he watched the tall occultist hurry down the street, a woman came out of the adjoining house. She caught sight of him, and her huge breasts heaved. She burst into a shrill, angry tirade.
Carson turned, staring at her with astonished eyes. His head throbbed painfully. The woman was approaching, shaking a fat fist threateningly.
“Why you scare my Sarah?” she cried, her swarthy face flushed. “Why you scare her wit’ your fool tricks, eh?” Carson moistened his lips.
“I’m sorry,” he said slowly. “Very sorry. I didn’t frighten your Sarah. I haven’t been home all day. What frightened her?”
“T’e brown t’ing — it ran in your house, Sarah say—”
The woman paused, and her jaw dropped. Her eyes widened. She made a peculiar sign with her right hand — pointing her index and little fingers at Carson, while her thumb was crossed over the other fingers. “T’e old witch!”