Deogaire was certainly capable of wielding the instrument. But who else had such strength? Then she suddenly asked herself why she had this curious reticence about condemning him. Everything seemed to fit. His antipathy; his threat — or warning, as he would have it; the coincidence that he had been ejected from his relative’s house, having provoked that action. . she was not overlooking the fact that Deogaire had provoked the argument in spite of Brother Conchobhar’s excuses.
‘Bring it with you,’ she smiled apologetically, handing the iron shaft back to him. ‘We need it as evidence.’ Then she turned and continued her examination of the wall, but nothing else seemed to present itself. She sighed and turned to the patient warrior. ‘Let’s go back down through the main building.’
They had come up through the guest quarters and now, as they turned to descend, she halted abruptly, nearly colliding with Gormán behind her. A figure was blocking the stairway. Brehon Aillín raised a pale, startled gaze to her.
She said nothing but merely stood regarding the old judge, whose chest was heaving.
‘I was just coming to get some fresh air,’ he gasped, as if he had run up the stairs.
‘I trust you are in good health, Brehon Aillín? You seem out of breath.’
Brehon Aillín drew himself up, his old arrogant self reappearing. ‘Very well,’ he said. ‘I will tell you the truth. Whether your brother likes it or not, I am Chief Brehon. I came to see if there was anything I could find that might be overlooked by a young, inexperienced dálaigh.’
For a moment Fidelma held back her reaction to smile. She wondered if the old man knew that Colgú had told her of his attempt to take legal action against Eadulf, and even against Colgú, having learned that he had asked the Council of Brehons to meet and elect a new Chief Brehon. Brehon Aillín was certainly his own worst advocate. She did feel sympathy for his age and experience, but there came a time when people should retire with dignity.
‘You are welcome to examine the roof all you want,’ she replied. ‘We have already done so. I do not think there will be much that you will be able to find now.’
Brehon Aillín scowled, turned and continued to climb the stairs onto the roof. As he did so, Fidelma saw his eyes fall on the iron shaft that Gormán still held. She saw his eyes widen a fraction and his mouth open a little. It was only for a moment and then his features assumed their usual expression of disdain. Fidelma was sure the old man had recognised the iron tool. A series of thoughts registered. Could she have been entirely wrong? Did Aillín have strength enough that he could have levered the statue from its place to fall on her and Eadulf as they passed? Had he come to the roof because he remembered that he had dropped the iron bar as he fled and now sought to retrieve it? It seemed impossible. But what was the meaning of the expression when his eyes fell on the metal bar? Well, it was no use pursuing that line at the moment. It would have to wait until she could manipulate the right situation.
Gormán cleared his throat uneasily. ‘Lady?’ he prompted, wondering why she still stood in the stairway. She gave him a quick smile and continued down the stairs. The guest chambers seemed to be deserted. An attendant was cleaning the rooms and so they passed on by. At the bottom of the stairway they met a troubled-looking Dar Luga, the housekeeper.
‘Good morning, lady,’ she greeted nervously. ‘Is everything all right? Is there anything I can do?’
Fidelma reached forward and patted the woman’s arm.
‘Do not worry yourself, Dar Luga. There was nothing you could have done about last night. I presume all the guests have risen?’
‘They have, lady.’
‘Where are they now?’
‘Brehon Aillín is still in the rooms above. .’
‘We saw him,’ Fidelma acknowledged.
‘The abbess and her steward have gone to the library. So has Brother Madagan. The abbot is in the council chamber with your brother.’
Fidelma turned and pointed to the iron lever that Gormán held. ‘Have you ever seen this before?’
The woman took a step forward to peer at it. Then she stood back with a shake of her head, saying, ‘It looks like a tool of some description.’
‘We think that it might be a builder’s tool of some sort,’ Fidelma agreed.
‘Perhaps you could ask the rathbuigé, the builder in charge of the repair work on the wall,’ Dar Luga suggested. ‘He might be able to tell you what it is.’
‘Just to clarify: have you ever seen such an instrument in this building before?’
‘Never.’
Fidelma allowed the housekeeper to continue on to the kitchens while she and Gormán went out of the main doors and into the courtyard.
‘If it is a tool from the site, the would-be assassin must have carried it into the guest quarters,’ mused Fidelma as she crossed the courtyard with the warrior. ‘He waited until he knew we were leaving the feasting hall, then went up to the roof, knowing that Eadulf and I would take the narrow passage to our own quarters, and worked swiftly to push the statue down on us.’ She frowned, halting suddenly in the middle of the courtyard. ‘That requires an awful lot of effort and luck.’
Gormán regarded her for a moment. ‘You don’t think it worked like that?’
‘It throws up too many questions.’
‘I don’t follow, lady.’
‘To carry the iron bar, which is difficult — even impossible — to conceal, the would-be assassin could not have done so on the spur of the moment. It was carefully planned beforehand. They would have had to take it to their room or the roof when there was no one who might encounter them. Do the guards come on duty just before the guests retire, or afterwards?’
‘Just afterwards, lady. As soon as it is known the guests have retired for the night.’
‘There would not have been time for any guest to leave the feasting hall, find the metal bar and take it up to their rooms. No, this bar was carried up there before the meal started.’
‘Unless they had not attended the meal, such as Deogaire.’
‘Or Brehon Aillín,’ countered Fidelma. ‘Even so, I don’t like it. Even if the iron bar was carried up earlier, the right statue still had to be selected — one overlooking the narrow passage. The would-be assassin had to know the precise time Eadulf and I left the feasting hall; had to know which of the two ways back to our chambers we might choose. And finally, they must have known exactly how long it would take to dislodge the statue and judge the time from the moment it was known we entered the passage to where we would be when the statue fell. In short, the would-be assassin, acting alone, must have been a miracle worker.’
Gormán gave an involuntary shiver. ‘You mean that there are evil spirits at work here?’ His voice dropped to an awed whisper.
‘Shame on you, Gormán!’ Fidelma stamped her foot. ‘No, I do not mean that at all! There is an answer to this and I will find it. Logic, in the very act of finding solutions, always throws up more questions.’
The young warrior was not really persuaded but he asked: ‘So, what next, lady?’
Fidelma glanced up at the sky to judge the time. Although she was pretending that the late night had not affected her, she felt drowsy and realised that she had to give into it.
‘I think I shall retire to my chambers for a while and wait until Eadulf returns with our son. That should be about midday. Then we shall question Deogaire. He will have had enough time to think about his position to realise he must give us honest answers.’
Gormán gestured to the iron bar in his hand. ‘What shall I do with this?’
‘Put it somewhere safe in the Laochtech for the time being. We’ll see what Deogaire has to say about it later.’
Fidelma had barely entered her chamber, sat down on the bed and closed her eyes when the next thing she was aware of was Eadulf coming into the room. Guiltily, she sat up, rubbing her eyes.