Betsy had never fit in in her hometown. Growing up in Goose Harbor, living here as an adult. She wasn't an old Yankee, a summer person, a fisherman, a part of the tourist industry. She was a nurse. Her mother had been a nurse, too. Her father had died in the very early days of Vietnam. That was the one thing she'd had in common with Olivia West-a close relative killed in war.
Luke pretended he didn't give a damn about fitting in, but Betsy thought his contempt for such trivialities was a defense mechanism. She thought he was a man who desperately wanted to fit in somewhere, anywhere. He romanticized small-town life.
She watched him pour a glass of champagne and hand it to Stick Monroe. Betsy felt the room spin a little more. Stick was definitely a man who didn't worry about fitting in. If people liked him, fine. If they didn't, fine. But it wasn't something he had to pay attention to-people generally liked him. He was handsome, successful, confident, imposing yet well-mannered, authentic. People tended not to like people who always fretted about whether or not they were liked.
Stick was saying something about Zoe West and that FBI agent. Betsy leaned forward in the soft cushions and forced herself to concentrate, placed her fingertips at her temples as if that could still the spinning in her head. Stick had on shorts and a sweatshirt in spite of the chilly evening. Betsy was almost thirty years younger than he was, but she expected he had more energy now than she did at her best, when she wasn't feeling the effects of three glasses of champagne.
"You have no idea what's going on with these break-ins?" Stick asked.
Betsy sat back abruptly at the obvious insinuation and expected Luke to throw Stick off the boat. But Luke, in khakis and a pale blue cashmere sweater, remained on his feet and didn't react heatedly. "Of course not. Why would I?"
"Kyle-"
"Kyle's not involved."
"He's Christina's boyfriend. He lives at the café."
Luke narrowed his eyes. "Are you suggesting my son could be the target of the break-ins?"
Stick shook his head. "I'm not suggesting anything."
Luke came around from the bar, his skin color a bit off. Betsy suspected the conversation was more unsettling to him than he wanted Stick to know. They'd been friends for years-both had adored Olivia West and considered Patrick their friend.
Stick let the stem of his glass slide between two fingers. "What do you know about this FBI agent?"
"Nothing," Luke said. "His name's J. B. McGrath. He rented a boat from Bruce Young. He's on vacation. He's been beating everyone at darts. He annoys people, I think."
"Kyle?"
Luke didn't answer at once. Betsy knew he wouldn't want to involve his son in a discussion about a mysterious FBI agent in town. For all his oddities, Luke did love his only child. "I don't think Kyle's had anything to do with him, frankly."
Stick drank more of his champagne. "McGrath seems very interested in Zoe."
"Do you think he hasn't been straight with everyone about his reasons for being here? Isn't that illegal, or at least unethical for an FBI agent?"
"I don't know. I just worry about Zoe." Stick smiled, almost embarrassed. "I guess I can't help it."
Betsy tried to make eye contact with Luke, but he wouldn't look at her, or simply had forgotten she was there. She had no idea where Stick was going with this conversation. He'd always treated Zoe like some kind of protégée, ever since she was a little kid and he was the well-connected, respected judge. He'd believed Zoe could do anything. When she'd been accepted to the FBI Academy, Stick said she could be the first female FBI director if she wanted to.
Betsy wondered if Zoe was a disappointment to him now that her father's murder and her aunt's death had thrown her into a tailspin. Not only did she not go to the academy, she'd run off to a small town in Connecticut and got herself fired from her police job there.
But Stick would never say a bad word about Zoe West, and if she wanted him to, he'd help her pick up the pieces of her career and figure out what to do next. Betsy was convinced of that.
Olivia had always been suspicious of Zoe's commitment to law enforcement and often wondered aloud to Betsy about whether her niece would stick with it or burn out before she was thirty-five. Olivia would sigh and say, then what? Then what would Zoe do? Now it seemed almost like a premonition.
"I have nothing to hide," Luke said. "If that's what you're implying."
Stick sank onto the far end of the couch, at least two yards from Betsy. He was another one who'd watched Luke grow up, summer to summer, in Goose Harbor, who'd known what wretches his parents were. Stick cupped his champagne glass in his palm, the stem between his fingers. "What about Teddy Shelton?" he asked.
Clearly caught off guard, Luke staggered back toward the bar. He placed one hand on the polished wood and steadied himself. Betsy could see he was rattled. No wonder. Teddy Shelton was a creep. She frowned at Stick, but he ignored her. He wasn't the old friend anymore but the truth-seeking judge, the arbiter of justice. He was neither kind nor unkind. That wasn't his role, not at this moment. He wanted the truth and thought he'd get it by intimidating and blindsiding Luke.
"Luke's got nothing to do with that dirtbag Shelton." Betsy jumped to her feet, prompting a wave of dizziness so profound she thought she might vomit. Heat surged up through her, fierce enough that it seemed to make even her hair feel hot, but she didn't back off. "Stick, what's the matter with you, coming in here like this and insinuating Luke's done something wrong?"
He didn't spare her so much as a glance, his incisive judge-eyes staying on Luke, as if he could see right through him and read his mind. "Luke?"
"You're talking through your hat." Luke's voice was calm, but Betsy could see he was shaken, if only from the insult. If Stick Monroe thought he was mixed up with the likes of Teddy Shelton, who else did? "You don't know anything."
"Call him off, Luke." Stick spoke in a quiet, measured voice, but there was no mistaking his seriousness. "You can't control a man like Teddy Shelton. I don't care how innocent your arrangement with him sounds to you, trust me that it won't sound that way to anyone else."
Her head spinning, her hands sweaty, Betsy staggered toward the two men. "What arrangement?"
Neither answered. She might have been invisible.
Luke's nostrils flared. His lips thinned and took on a purplish tint, but Betsy hoped it was just a combination of the lighting and his emotions, usually so repressed, rising to the surface. He was such a hypochondriac that if he were in real medical trouble, he'd throw Stick out and have Betsy call an ambulance.
"Do yourself a favor and head south," Stick went on. His tone was gentle now, the calm, wise older friend giving Luke sound advice. "You're normally gone by now, anyway. No one will think twice about it. There's no point staying here any longer. Call Teddy Shelton off and leave. Then you won't have to worry about people jumping to the wrong conclusions."
"Zoe and that FBI agent, you mean," Luke said.
Stick nodded. "Precisely."
"I had nothing to do with Patrick's death." Luke's voice was raspy, as if he were being strangled. "Neither did Shelton."
"I didn't say I or anyone else suspect you of any wrongdoing. I just don't think you want the likes of Zoe West and J. B. McGrath asking questions about why you hired Teddy Shelton." Unruffled, Stick polished off the last of his champagne and got slowly to his feet. He set the glass on the bar. "They're going to want to know who you suspect of wrongdoing. How far will you go-"
"Go to hell!"
Luke reared back to punch Stick, but the old judge shook his head, as if his disapproval alone would be enough to ward off the attack. It was. Luke backed away, breathing in rapid, shallow gulps, spit oozing out at the corners of his mouth. Betsy had never seen him so angry.