‘Thoroughbreds that had clean passports. No Section Nine declaration.’
‘So they could go for human consumption.’
‘Yes.’
Hitchens looked at her interview notes, as if he thought he might be missing something. ‘And her story is that she went to the meeting alone, on horseback.’
‘Because it was more anonymous, and easier to make a getaway.’
‘Right. And all she intended was to give Mr Rawson a scare. In her own words, “to teach him a lesson”. But when she galloped her horse at him, Mr Rawson tripped and fell. The horse spooked and reared, and he got kicked in the head. That’s it?’
‘Pretty much,’ agreed Fry.
‘In her account, there were no witnesses.’
‘No.’
‘And without a witness, it would be difficult to prove that it happened any differently. It could have been an accident.’
Fry nodded. ‘It’s funny,’ she said. ‘We started off with the assumption that Patrick Rawson’s killing was the result of some human relationship that had gone wrong.’
‘Well, that’s usually the case, Diane.’
‘Yes. But, in the end, it turns out that Rawson died because of the nature of someone’s relationship with an animal. That’s a new one on me.’
‘And me.’
‘The trouble is,’ said Fry, ‘Naomi Widdowson obviously knows nothing at all about what happened to Michael Clay.’
‘So are we accepting Miss Widdowson’s account?’ asked Hitchens.
‘No, we’re not,’ said Fry. ‘Because we know that she wasn’t on her own.’
‘She’s shielding someone, then. Her brother?’
‘I don’t think so.’
Fry took the postmortem photos of Patrick Rawson’s head injury from her case file and lay them on Hitchens’ desk.
‘Mrs van Doon has completed her analysis of the injury pattern,’ she said. ‘As we can see, the depression in the skull is basically the shape of a horseshoe, which would substantiate Naomi Widdowson’s story. But this area here, where the pattern has been obliterated – that was caused by a later injury. Mrs van Doon thinks a blunt-ended weapon.’
Hitchens examined the photos closely. ‘Interesting. So someone finished Patrick Rawson off.’
‘That’s our murderer,’ said Fry. ‘It’s whoever the second person was who went to that meeting with Naomi Widdowson. It’s the person she’s shielding. And it’s someone who had a reason for making sure that Patrick Rawson was dead.’
Cooper knew only too well how an overnight resolve could dissipate completely by morning. You went to bed with your mind full of determination, and by the time you got up your willpower was as mushy as the muesli in your breakfast bowl. Things seemed so much less important in the cold light of day. Easier, surely, to let it all go by and get on with life.
But that morning, a couple of hours before dawn, he had already been wide awake and planning how he would carry out his intention.
‘You’re getting really good at these interviews,’ said Cooper in the CID room.
‘I always was good,’ said Fry.
‘No, I mean – you really knew how to handle the Widdowsons. They’re going to give more away about what happened at any moment.’
‘If they have anything more to give away.’
Cooper turned. ‘What? Do you think they might be genuine?’
‘I’ve no idea, Ben.’
‘Oh.’
Cooper wasn’t quite sure how Fry had managed to make him feel in the wrong when all he had tried to do was pay her a professional compliment.
‘You know,’ he said, ‘if something’s bothering you, you should talk about it.’
Fry looked at him, a cool expression on her face that he couldn’t read. Sometimes, it seemed to be an expression that she put on entirely for his benefit, a mask that he wasn’t supposed to penetrate.
‘Ben,’ she said, ‘if I was going to talk to someone about what’s bothering me – it certainly wouldn’t be you.’
Cooper sat back, feeling the physical force of her rebuff.
‘OK. It’s up to you.’
‘Yes, it is.’
‘I’m being serious, Diane.’
‘No, you’re being ludicrous. There’s a difference.’
‘I’m sorry you feel like that,’ said Cooper. ‘Because I wanted to ask you something.’
Just then, Gavin Murfin came into the office with a report in his hand.
‘Fingerprint section have got their, er… fingers out at last,’ he said, with a grin. ‘They’ve got us a result on the prints lifted from the gate in that field where Patrick Rawson died.’
‘And…?’ said Fry, completely forgetting Cooper.
Murfin scanned the report. ‘Adrian Tarrant, aged thirty- two. HGV driver, with an address in Eyam.’
‘He has a record? If his prints were on file, they should have made the match long before now. Days ago.’
Murfin shook his head. ‘They weren’t on file until today,’ he said. ‘He was arrested this morning, during a meeting of the Eden Valley Hunt.’
‘What?’ said Cooper. ‘We were there.’
‘Well, you must have missed it. It seems Mr Tarrant was identified by a female hunt saboteur as the person who assaulted her during an incident on Tuesday. He was arrested and brought here for processing. DNA sample and fingerprints taken, as per routine.’
‘And when they put his prints into the system, they got a match.’
‘Bingo,’ smiled Murfin.
‘Adrian Tarrant,’ said Fry. ‘I knew it was him.’
Adrian Tarrant had been employed by one of the haulage companies whose lorries rumbled constantly backwards and forwards to the opencast quarries on Longstone Edge. Fry reflected that he might well have seen her as he passed along the haulage road in a cloud of dust. But she wondered whether his job might not give an alibi for eight thirty on Tuesday morning, when Patrick Rawson was killed.
That was, until she discovered Tarrant had been sacked by his employers the previous week, for turning up over the alcohol limit once too often.
The house in Eyam was already guarded by uniformed officers standing at the gate. It was a small, stone-faced council house, not much more than a two-up, two-down, with a tiny kitchen and bathroom. According to the neighbours, Adrian Tarrant shared the house with another man, possibly a cousin, who worked as a long-distance lorry driver and was currently away on a job.
Fry could see from the state of the house that this was likely to be true. A couple of days’ washing-up stood on the kitchen drainer, newspapers and empty beer cans decorated the carpet in the sitting room. The TV remote looked much better used than the vacuum cleaner.
The team moved through the house systematically, not entirely sure what they were looking for, so looking that bit more carefully.
‘Apparently, it was Tarrant’s fellow hunt stewards who pointed the finger initially,’ said Cooper. ‘Then, when he was pulled in, the girl he injured made a positive identification. So it just shows -’
‘Not all hunting people are bad, I know,’ said Fry.
‘They can’t risk someone like him giving them a bad reputation. Not any more.’
In the sitting room, Fry began to open the drawers of a small dresser, her gloved fingers moving through the contents. Some CDs, spare batteries, a pair of gloves. Luke Irvine was examining a desktop PC on a table in the corner. Was Tarrant the type to send a lot of emails? She doubted it, but you had to check. Just as Cooper came into the room from the kitchen, she touched something solid in the drawer. Her fingers closed around an unusual shape.
‘That’s odd.’
Cooper came over to her. ‘What have you found, Diane?’
‘I’m not sure.’
Fry showed him the object she’d found in the drawer – a small, flared brass and copper tube, no more than nine inches long.
‘Those things aren’t easy to use,’ said Cooper. ‘It takes a lot of practice to get it right.’
‘What is it?’
‘A hunting horn, of course.’
Carefully, Fry bagged the horn for evidence.
‘Adrian Tarrant must have had it,’ she said. ‘So it looks as though the kill call was real, after all – and Tarrant was the one who blew it. For a while, I thought the sabs were making it up.’