Aster sat at a small table, looking up at the tutor’s podium. The old Cinnae smiled encouragingly, and Aster began the lines again.
“Information without practice can never grow to knowledge. Knowledge without silence can never grow to wisdom. And so practice and silence, doing and not doing, are at the heart of the right man’s path.”
“Marras Toca,” Geder said. “I didn’t know you were learning military philosophy.”
The tutor’s watery smile greeted him as he stepped into the room.
“You know the text, my Lord Regent?” he asked.
“I read an essay mentioning him that was very important to me. Afterward, I made a point of finding some of his work. I made a translation of it over the winter. I didn’t use silence in mine. I thought stillness was closer to the original meaning.”
“I think it’s dull,” Aster said.
“Some of it’s dry,” Geder said. The room was small, but sun-warmed. “Some of it was pretty interesting, though. Did you read the section about the spiritual exercises?”
“Like a cunning man’s tricks?” Aster said, brightening a little.
“No, they were more like ways to practice thinking. When he’s talking about silence or stillness, it’s not just about not moving around. He’s got a particular technical meaning.”
“Have you done the exercises, my Lord Regent?” the tutor asked.
“No, not really, but I read about them a lot, and I think it’s very interesting. Wise, even,” Geder said, and leaned close to Aster with a rueful little grin. “I’m better at reading about those kinds of things than doing them. Can I see the translation you’re using?”
The tutor leaned over his podium and held out the book. Geder took it carefully. It was very old, and the binding was leather and string. The pages were cloth, and thicker than usual, which gave the thing a feeling of solidity and weight. Geder turned the pages reverently.
“It’s beautiful,” he said. “Where did you get it?”
“A teacher of mine gave it to me when I was hardly older than Prince Aster,” the tutor said, smiling. “I’ve kept it with me ever since. I have heard that you have quite the sizable library yourself, my Lord Regent?”
“Well, I wouldn’t go that far. I used to have more time to read. And translate. I was working on an essay that tracked the royal houses of Elassae by the dates of their births, and it argued that Timzinae have two annual mating seasons. The actual dates were a little sketchy, but the argument was brilliant.”
Aster sighed and leaned his elbows against his desk, but the old tutor’s eyes were alight.
“It sounds fascinating, my lord. Do you recall the name of the author?”
“It was speculative essay, and only about three hundred years ago, so it had an attribution, but…”
“Yes, not much use to it. Not in those days,” the tutor agreed.
Geder turned the pages, the cloth softer than skin under his fingertips. Toca’s section on battle maps looked different in this than the one Geder had. There were at least three more diagrams, and a table of comparison that must have been added in by a later scribe. He traced the ancient ink with his fingertips.
“Could I borrow this?” Geder asked. “I’d like to compare it to mine.”
The tutor’s expression froze, and his hands made small spider’s fists.
“Of course, my lord,” he said. “I would be honored.”
“Thank you,” Geder said. “I will bring it back. I’m just going to go put it in with my books, if you don’t mind.” “Of course not,” the tutor said.
“Does that mean we can do something else?” Aster asked as Geder walked out of the room. The boy’s voice sounded hopeful.
Geder walked with the pages open before him, his finger tracing the words. A little glow of excitement warmed him.
This wasn’t a translation he’d ever seen before, and the original text seemed more complete than the one he’d worked with.
The goal of war is peace. The small general leads his army into battle to achieve victory, and so his own nature will force him to return to it. The deep general leads his army into battle to confirm victory, and so the world’s nature will force him to return to it. The wise general leads his army into battle to reshape the world, and so he creates a place which does not need him.
It wasn’t at all like the copy Geder had. His copy hadn’t, he was almost sure, included the verse about the deep general. Deep wasn’t a form Toca used often, and when he did it was usually in reference to the priesthood. Geder wondered if a discussion of warrior priests had been taken out by a later translator.
“Ah,” Basrahip said. “Listening to empty voices again, Prince Geder?”
The high priest was in the main room, sitting on a cushioned bench with his hands on his knees.
“I like books,” Geder said.
“Some are pretty, but they are toys. They mean nothing.”
“Well,” Geder said, closing the book and setting it aside, “it’s something we’re just going to disagree about.”
“For now,” Basrahip agreed.
Geder sat beside the window. The afternoon sun pressed on the back of his hand.
“What did you find out?”
It was little that Geder hadn’t expected. The court was certain that victory was imminent, and the credit for that rested with Geder and his ally and onetime patron Dawson Kalliam. Opinion about how to deal with their conquered neighbor was mixed, but the disagreements were between gentlemen. Of course, there were particulars. One man advocated waiting for Baron Watermarch’s return from North-coast. Another thought that a marriage between Aster and Asterilhold’s Princess Lisbet should be arranged as soon as the suit of peace arrived. Geder might draw the war out long enough to destroy the farmlands and mills and shipyards of the enemy, or he might preserve them for the use of the combined kingdoms in later years.
They talked for hours as the sun slid westward, pulling Camnipol slowly into the red light of sunset, the grey of dusk, and then darkness. The moon had not risen, and the stars shone in the high summer sky. At last, Geder, his head overfull, made his apologies and took himself to bed where men he didn’t know undressed him, powdered his body, and laid him under thin spring blankets. Half awake, he was annoyed to discover that he’d forgotten the tutor’s book. It would have been pleasant to read for a little while before sleep. He had so little time to read anymore…
Morning came clear and cold. He lay in bed for a while, watching the sunlight stream through the windows. Then the ritual humiliation, and he stepped out into the royal family dining hall. Basrahip was already there, as was Aster. The two were talking about something, Basrahip smiling and Aster laughing aloud. Geder sat, and a young servant brought him a length of baked duck and stewed pears, a small loaf of sweet black bread, and honeyed coffee with the grounds thick as mud at the bottom.
“Did I miss something funny?” Geder asked.
“Minister Basrahip’s been doing impressions of the men in court,” Aster said.
“Are they good?”
“No,” Aster said, hooting. “They’re terrible.”
Basrahip smiled.
“I am no man to play pretend,” he said. “It is not what I am.”
“And thank God for that,” Geder said, plucking a bit of the duck free and popping it in his mouth. It was salty and rich and entirely the perfect way to begin a morning. “I’ve been thinking about the terms of peace with Asterilhold. I think I know what we have to do.”
Priest and boy both sobered, turning their attention to him. Geder sipped the coffee, enjoying the moment of suspense more than he probably should have.