By the time they arrived at Glenrothes, dusk was settling.
Jerry McGovern was already in Interview Room 2. He looked frail compared to Gilchrist’s recollection of his brother, Malky, with bedraggled hair and a lantern jaw that aged him by at least ten years. He looked as if he had lived all of his life in the shadow of a bigger, older brother. Or maybe he was just the runt of the litter.
By his side sat a young woman, no more than thirty, Gilchrist guessed, with spiked blonde hair and black-rimmed designer glasses. She stood and held out her hand.
Gilchrist ignored it and took his seat without a word. Jessie did likewise. He switched on the recorder and formally introduced himself and Jessie, stated date and time, and added that they were interviewing Jerry McGovern with respect to the deaths of the McCulloch family. He then confirmed that Mr McGovern was accompanied by his solicitor, at which point he looked across at the young woman.
‘Ali McCrae,’ she said, ‘R. K. Leith & Associates, Dundee.’ She handed Gilchrist her card, and slid another across the table to Jessie.
Gilchrist faced McGovern. ‘You’ve confessed to stealing jewellery,’ he said.
McGovern nodded. ‘That’s all I done. I didnae kill anyone-’
‘Just answer the questions one at a time,’ Gilchrist said.
McGovern pursed his lips, lowered his head. He could be a scolded child.
McCrae leaned forward. ‘My client has categorically denied any involvement in the murder of the-’
‘So he says,’ Jessie interrupted. ‘What else does he say?’
McCrae frowned. ‘Haven’t you read his statement?’
‘We’re not interested in his statement. We’re here to ask him-’
‘We’ve already been through this.’
‘This?’ Gilchrist said.
‘My client’s whereabouts on the night in question.’
‘And which night was that?’
‘Please tell me you’re not serious.’
Gilchrist sat back in his chair and eyed McCrae. Anger and incredulity seemed to lift off her like heat from rock. ‘I’m serious,’ he said.
‘If that were true, you would’ve made sure you knew all the facts before-’
‘If we knew all the facts,’ Jessie cut in, her Glasgow accent as heavy as a punch to the gut, ‘we wouldn’t be here asking questions, would we?’
McCrae glared at her for a long moment, then slumped back in her seat.
Jessie turned to McGovern. ‘Why don’t you tell us where you were on Thursday evening?’
‘I have to instruct my client not to answer-’
‘On what grounds?’ Jessie snapped.
‘On the grounds that he has already supplied the police with-’
‘You worried he might incriminate himself this time?’
‘That’s ridiculous.’
‘Mr McGovern,’ Gilchrist interrupted. ‘I have to tell you that even though your solicitor will assure you that she is protecting your rights, she is doing you no favours at all here.’
McCrae slapped her pen on to the table. ‘I’ve heard it all now.’
‘Do you understand?’ Gilchrist asked him.
‘Don’t answer that.’
McGovern swallowed, a hard dunking of his Adam’s apple. When McCrae reached for his arm, he shrugged her off. ‘I’ve done nothing wrong,’ he said.
‘Since when has stealing jewellery been legal?’ Jessie asked.
‘Aye, okay. But I’ve no killed nobody.’
‘Once again, my client denies any involvement in-’
‘I’ve nothing to be afraid of,’ McGovern interrupted.
‘You’ve plenty to be-’
‘You’re no listening to me,’ McGovern snapped at McCrae, who seemed surprised by his angry tone.
‘Jerry,’ she said, ‘you need to-’
‘Shut it, yeah?’
McCrae’s eyes sparked with fury. ‘Look,’ she said, ‘you’ve-’
‘Look nothing. I want to clear my name.’
Give McCrae her due. She dropped the aggressive tone as easily as casting off a coat, and said, ‘Fine. I’ll take notes, Jerry.’ She raised her hand to ward off any complaint. ‘And I won’t say another word, I promise. Okay?’ She could have been speaking to a temperamental child.
McGovern glanced at Gilchrist, then Jessie, then back to Gilchrist, and nodded.
Gilchrist was about to speak when McCrae reached for the recorder and switched it off. ‘I’m going to listen very carefully to everything you two ask my client. Be warned, I will take this further if I consider-’
‘Where do you get off?’ snarled Jessie, and switched the recorder back on. ‘Right,’ she said to McGovern. ‘For the record, you have instructed your solicitor not to intervene on your behalf. Is that correct?’
McGovern nodded.
‘Please speak for the record,’ Jessie said.
‘That’s correct.’
Gilchrist caught McGovern’s nervous glance at McCrae, and realised that the man was more frightened of his solicitor than he was of the police. As long as McCrae was in the interview room, Gilchrist doubted that McGovern would open up to them. So he said, ‘Would you like your solicitor to leave?’
‘Now wait just a minute.’
‘I’m not speaking to you, Ms McCrae,’ Gilchrist said. ‘But I’ll repeat the question for your client.’ He waited a couple of beats, then said, ‘Would you like your solicitor to leave the room?’
A sullen shrug.
‘Please speak for the record.’
‘Aye,’ McGovern said, shifting on his seat, as if distancing himself a crucial inch or two from McCrae.
‘And, in the absence of legal assistance, would you like to continue with the interview?’
‘I would.’
‘I can’t recommend this, Jerry. You’re making a big mistake.’
McGovern cast another nervous glance in her direction, as if fearful that holding her gaze might petrify him. ‘You can listen to the recording,’ he said, then looked at Gilchrist. ‘She can, can’t she?’
Gilchrist nodded. ‘She can.’
‘But by then you might have dug a hole too deep for me to be able to help you.’
‘I’ll take my chances.’
‘It’s your life.’ McCrae pushed to her feet and walked to the door.
Jessie lifted her business card and said, ‘Ali McCrae of R. K. Leith & Associates is now leaving the interview room.’ She glanced at the wall clock and confirmed the time.
McCrae left with a parting scowl at Jessie.
When the door closed, McGovern’s eyes darted left and right, as if expecting McCrae to pop out of thin air and frighten him. Or maybe he was just a scared kind of guy, not someone capable of killing an entire family. But psychopaths rarely fitted preconceived ideas of how they should behave, so Gilchrist knew he still had to tread with care.
‘Where were you on Thursday night?’ he asked McGovern.
‘At home.’
‘Anybody with you?’
‘No.’
‘Did you steal jewellery from the McCullochs’ house?’
‘Yes. But that’s all I done. I didnae kill anyone.’
Gilchrist folded his arms and sat back. ‘Talk us through it, Jerry.’
Neither he nor Jessie said a word as McGovern explained that he had staked out the McCullochs’ home off and on over a three-week period, noted who came and went, what time Brian McCulloch went to work, when Amy took the children to school, when they came home.
‘All by yourself?’ Jessie asked.
McGovern gave a tic for a glance, and Gilchrist knew the next words out of his mouth would be a lie. ‘Me and Malky.’
Gilchrist watched McGovern’s eyes dance after the lie. Roping in his dead brother was as good a way as any to cover up the involvement of others. ‘Malky’s been dead for a wee while,’ Gilchrist said to him. ‘So I guess you did it all by yourself last week?’
McGovern nodded, a tad unsure. ‘Aye.’
‘So, why Thursday morning?’ Gilchrist pressed.
‘The cleaner works Mondays and Fridays.’
‘Which made Thursday morning the best time to break in?’