Hastings should not be so trusting.
Catesby was saying that he could not believe this was really true, but he feared it was. Hastings was in communication with the Queen.
‘How so?’ asked Richard.
‘By way of Jane Shore. She visits the Queen in Sanctuary. I have watched her. I have paid people in the Sanctuary to listen to what is said between the Queen and Mistress Shore.’
‘And Hastings?’
‘My lord, he is ready to betray you, to take sides with the Woodvilles, to get the Queen out of Sanctuary and rouse the people to the side of the King. The King thinks his mother and uncle can do no wrong.’
‘I know that well,’ said Richard. ‘He has made that obvious to me.’
‘Hastings has hinted to me what is in his mind,’ said Catesby. ‘He trusts me. He looks on me as his man. My lord, I owe my allegiance to you ... not to Hastings. Thus I have undertaken the painful task of telling you what is in his mind and what I have discovered about him.’
‘It is a grievous shock to me,’ said Richard. ‘I trusted Hastings. He was my brother’s best friend.’
‘My lord you should trust him no more.’
‘Rest assured I shall not, and when I have discovered that there is indeed a plot I shall know how to act.’
Catesby said: ‘Then I have done my duty.’
‘I thank you. This shall be dealt with. And in the meantime watch for me. Let me know if there is anything more passing between them. Find out all you can of how Hastings conducts himself.’
Catesby swore that he would.
After he had left Buckingham called on Richard and was told what Catesby had revealed. Buckingham listened intently.
‘Hastings was always a fool,’ he said. ‘There is only one way to deal with traitors even if they are fools.’
‘So thought I,’ said Richard. ‘But there is more to discover yet. Buckingham, there is something else of great moment that I would say to you. Stillington has been to me with a strange revelation. He says that my brother was not indeed married to Elizabeth Woodville.’
‘Can this really be so?’
‘So says he. He married my brother to Lady Eleanor Butler,’
‘By God! Old Shrewsbury’s daughter. Eleanor was my cousin – my sister’s daughter. She would have been more suitable to be Queen of England than the Woodville woman.’
‘Yes, you are right. Eleanor Butler went into a convent and died there, but several years after my brother’s so called marriage with Elizabeth Woodville.’
‘Then, Richard, you are King of England.’
‘It would seem so ... if Stillington speaks truth.’
‘Why should he not speak truth?’
‘These are weighty matters. They must be proved.’
‘By God, they must be. And when they are ... This is good news. We shall have a mature king, a king who knows how to govern. There will be no regency ... no protectorate ... no boy King. It is an answer from Heaven.’
‘Not so fast, my lord. First we must prove it. There is much to be done. What I fear more than anything is to plunge this country into civil war. We have had enough of that. We want no more wars.’
‘But you must be proclaimed King.’
‘Not yet. Let us wait. Let it be proved. Let us test the mood of the people.’
‘The people will acclaim their true King.’
‘We must first make sure that they are ready to do so.’
Richard stared ahead of him. He had let out the secret. That it would have tremendous consequences he had no doubt.
It was a devastating discovery. Men such as Buckingham could act rashly. Buckingham’s idea was that Richard should immediately claim the throne. It was what Buckingham would have done had he been in Richard’s position. As a matter of fact Buckingham himself believed that he had claim to the throne – a flimsy one it was true but he made it clear sometimes that he was aware of it.
Richard found himself in a quandary. He wanted to be in command because he knew he was capable of ruling. He had proved that by the order he had kept in the North. He wanted to keep the country prosperous and at peace and the last thing he wanted was a civil war.
The young King disliked him more every day and one of the main reasons was that he was imprisoning Lord Rivers and Richard Grey, and the fact that his mother was in Sanctuary. Young Edward blamed Gloucester for this, which was logical enough; but the King did not understand that his mother and his maternal relations would ruin the country if they ever came to complete power. Lord Rivers was indeed a charming man; he had become a champion in the jousts, he had all the Woodville good looks; he was quite saintly when he remembered to be but he was as avaricious as the rest of the family and he wanted to govern the King. That was what all the Woodvilles wanted. So did Richard for that matter. The difference was that Edward the Fourth had appointed his brother as Protector and guardian of the King for he knew – as Richard knew – that Richard alone was capable of governing the country in the wise strong way which the late King had followed.
Yet the King disliked his uncle. The only way in which Richard could win his regard was by freeing the Woodvilles and to do that he would have to become one of them. There were so many of them and they had gathered so much power and riches during Edward’s lifetime that they would absorb him. He would become a minor figure. He would in fact become a follower of the Woodvilles. It would mean too that he would have to sacrifice his friends – Buckingham, Northumberland, Catesby, Ratcliffe ... It was unthinkable. He ... a Plantagenet to become a hanger-on of the Woodvilles!
The alternative to all this was to take power himself. It seemed to him that he had every right to do this. In the first place he had been appointed by his brother to be the Protector of the Realm and the young King. And now Stillington had come along with this revelation. If it were indeed true that his brother had not been legally married to Elizabeth Woodville he, Richard of Gloucester, was the true King of England.
He could take power with a free conscience. If the people would accept him as their King, he could prevent civil war. He could rule in peace as his brother had done. It was his duty to take the crown. It was also becoming his dearest wish.
But he must go carefully. He had rarely ever been rash. He liked to weigh up a situation, decide on how to act, then consider the consequences – the good and the bad for there were invariably good and bad in all matters.
This marriage with Eleanor Butler would have to be proved. Its consequences would be so overwhelming that there must be no hurrying into a decision on it. He must have time to think on it.
In the meantime there were other pressing matters to be dealt with. Hastings, for instance. Hastings had great power. He had believed him to be loyal. Hastings had warned him of the King’s death and the need to come prepared to London. That had stood him in great stead. Without that warning he might not have heard of his brother’s death until after young Edward’s coronation and that would have been too late. He owed something to Hastings.
Yet Hastings was in touch with Elizabeth Woodville; he had seen the King. Jane Shore took messages to the Sanctuary. They were plotting against him. Richard hated disloyalty more than anything. He had chosen his motto ‘Loyalty binds me’ because it meant so much to him.
If Hastings were deceiving him, he deserved to die, and die he must, for he would be the link between the King and the Woodvilles and if his conspiracy were allowed to proceed it could be the end of Richard. They would have no compunction in beheading him, he knew. They hated and feared him; and the King could give his ready consent.
There must be prompt action. He sent for Richard Ratcliffe, a man whom he trusted. Ratcliffe had been Comptroller of King Edward’s household and his efficient management of affairs had aroused Richard’s interest in him. He came from Lancashire and Richard knew his family in the North. He was a man he trusted.