Detective Lieutenant Wilson T. Crane, noted for his research capabilities and expertise in computer technology…
Sergeant Boone opened the discussion by recapping briefly the circumstances of Leonard Bergdorfer's death…
"Pretty much like the others. Throat slashed. Multiple stab wounds in the nuts. This time the body was found on the floor. Take a look at the photos. The bed wasn't used. The autopsy shows no, uh, sexual relations prior-"
Bentley: "Sexual relations? You mean like my sister-in-law?" (Laughter) Boone: "He hadn't screwed at least twenty-four hours prior to his death. Like the others."
Crane: "Prints?"
Boone: "The Latent Print Unit is still at it. It doesn't look good. Two things that may help… The tip of a knife blade was found embedded in the victim's throat. It's a little more than a half-inch long. Lab Services is working on it now. There's no doubt it's from the murder weapon. Probably a pocket knife, jackknife, or clasp knife-whatever you want to call it."
Johnson: "How long was the blade do they figure?"
Boone: "Maybe three inches long."
Johnson: "Sheet! A toothpick."
Boone: "Victim suffered first-degree burns of the face, especially around the eyes and nose. The Medical Examiner's office blames phenacyl chloride used in CN and Chemical Mace. The burning indicates a heavy dose at close range."
Broderick: "Enough to knock him out?"
Boone: "Enough to knock him down, that's for sure. As far as the victim's background goes, we're still at it. No New York sheet. He was from Atlanta, Georgia. They're checking. Ditto the Feds. Probably nothing we can use. And that's about it."
Crane: "Was the Mace can found?"
Boone: "No. The killer probably took it along. What's the law on Mace? Anyone know?"
Slavin: "Illegal to buy, sell, own, carry, or use in the State of New York. Except for bona fide security and law enforcement officers."
Bentley: "Black market? Johnson?"
Johnson: "You asking me 'cause I'm black?" (Laughter) Johnson: "There's some of it around. In those little purse containers for women to carry. There's not what you'd call a thriving market on the street."
Boone: "Well, at the moment, the Mace and the knife blade tip are all we've got that's new. Before we start talking about what to do with them, I'd like you to listen to ex-Chief of Detectives Edward X. Delaney for a few minutes. The Chief is not on active duty. At the urging of Deputy Commissioner Ivar Thorsen and myself, he has agreed to serve as, uh, a consultant on this investigation. Chief?"
Delaney stood, leaning on his knuckles on the battered table. He loomed forward. He looked around slowly, staring at every man.
"I'm not here to give you orders," he said tonelessly. "I'm not here to ride herd on you. I've got no official status at all. I'm here because Thorsen and Boone are old friends, and because I want to crack this thing as much as you do. If I have any suggestions on how to run this case, I'll make them to Thorsen or Boone. They can pick up on them or not-that's their business. I just want to make sure you know what the situation is. I'd like my presence here to be kept under wraps as long as possible. I know it'll probably get out eventually, but I don't need the publicity. I've already got my pension."
They smiled at that, and relaxed.
"All right," he said, "now I want to tell you who I think the Hotel Ripper is…"
That jolted them and brought them leaning forward, waiting to hear.
He told them why he thought the killer was a woman. Not a prostitute, but a psychopathic female. He went over all the evidence he had presented to Monica and to Thorsen. But this time he remembered to include the additional detail that the person who tipped off the Times could have been a woman.
He said nothing about Thomas Handry's research, nothing about the statistics showing the increased evidence of alcoholism, drug addiction, and mental disturbance among women.
These men were professional policemen; they weren't interested in sociological change or psychological motivation. Their sole concern was evidence that could be brought into court.
So he came down heavily on the known facts about the murders, facts that could be accounted for only by the theory he proposed. They were facts already known to everyone in that room, except for his suggestion that the timing of the killings was equivalent to a woman's menstrual period.
But it was the first time they had heard these disparate items fitted into a coherent hypothesis. He could see their doubt turn to dawning realization that the theory he offered was a fresh approach, a new way of looking at old puzzles.
"So what we're looking for," Delaney concluded, "is a female crazy. I'd guess young-late twenties to middle thirties. Five-five to five-seven. Short hair, because she has no trouble wearing wigs. Strong. Very, very smart. Not a street bum. Probably a woman of some education and breeding. Chances are she's on pills or booze or both, but that's pure conjecture. She probably lives a reasonably normal life when she's not out slashing throats. Holds down a job, or maybe she's a housewife. That's all I've got."
He sat down suddenly. The men looked at one another, waiting for someone to speak.
BOONE: "Any reactions?"
SLAVIN: "There's not a goddamned thing there we can take to the DA."
BOONE: "Granted. But it's an approach. A place to start."
JOHNSON: "I'll buy it."
BENTLEY: "It listens to me. It's got to be a twist-all those straight guys stripping off their pants."
CRANE: "It doesn't fit the probabilities for this type of crime."
DELANEY: "I agree. In this case, I think the probabilities are wrong. Not wrong, but outdated."
BRODERICK: "I'll go along with you, Chief. Let's suppose the killer is a woman. So what? Where do we go from there?"
BOONE: "First, go back and check the records again. For women with a sheet that includes violent crimes. Check the prisons for recent releases. Check the booby hatches for ditto, and for escapees. Go through all our nut files and see if anything shows up."
CRANE: "My crew can handle that."
BOONE: "Second, the knife blade… Broderick, see if you can trace the knife by analysis of the metal in the blade."
DELANEY: "Or the shape. Ever notice how pocket knife blades have different shapes? Some are straight, some turn up at the point, some are sharpened on both edges."
BRODERICK: "That's nice. There must be a zillion different makes of pocket knives for sale in the New York area."
BOONE: "Find out. Third, Johnson you take the business with the Mace. Who makes it, how it gets into New York. Is it sold by mail order? Can you get a license to buy it? Anyone pushing it on the street? And so forth."
BENTLEY: "And me?"
BOONE: "Pull your decoys out of the gay bars. Concentrate on the straight places, and mostly the bars and cocktail lounges in mid town hotels. And show photos of the victims to bartenders and waitresses. See if you can pick up a trail."
BENTLEY: "We've already done that, sarge."
BOONE: "So? Do it again."
DELANEY: "Wait a minute…"
They all turned to look at him but the Chief was silent. Then he spoke to Detective Bentley.
DELANEY: "Your squad showed photos of all the victims around in hotel bars and cocktail lounges?"
BENTLEY: "That's right, Chief."
DELANEY: "And you came up with zilch?"
BENTLEY: "Correct. That's understandable; most of the places were mobbed. What waitress would remember one customer's face?"
DELANEY: "Uh-huh. Boone, who was the victim with the badly scarred hands?"
BOONE: "The third. Jerome Ashley, at the Hotel Coolidge."
DELANEY: "Go back to the Coolidge. Don't show Ashley's photo. At first. Ask if any waitress or bartender remembers a customer with badly scarred hands. If they do, then show his photo."