We rose as far as we ever had. We flowed back into ourselves, and I stirred the waters for one more full flood before returning to sea level. But as we crested one last time, I heard a ringing like a bell. Its attack was something only weather made. I hadn’t conducted it; it came from outside my students’ ranges, but nestled into their outlined harmonies, notes so sustained they were almost stopped. It took me an instant, forever, to place: my brother singing Dowland. The tune came from a life ago. The words from yesterday:
Bird and fish can fall in love.
I turned around to see, but Jonah waved me back again. He came alongside the end of the choir’s back row. The resonance he released rang like a gong. But my kids knew a good thing when they made one. I kept conducting, and they kept coming back in. I stole a look at Jonah. He lifted an eyebrow at me like he used to do, back in the day. And we were off.
Everywhere I brought my class, he found a way to follow. This time, I made him read my mind. Accompany me. Scraps of will-o’-the-wisp, poet love, songs of the death of children, the Dies Irae, old broken have-mercies: He fit them into the running chorus, changed by everything they harmonized. He gave them game. He sang in that high, clear, inevitable blade of light his whole lifetime had gone into perfecting. Even the children felt the power. Always the same seven words, scatting where he needed, as if born to it.
We circled on a giant updraft, drifting through the keys. His voice, joined to the voices of my children, was like a lamp in the night. We could have stayed up there for years, except for one accident. When he slipped into the classroom, Jonah failed to close the door. So every chant of “I’m still standing”— a little bit louder now; a little bit softer now — washed down the hall, the free property of anyone who heard. I didn’t realize we were disturbing the peace until the chorus joined in behind me.
A sober instructor of social studies came by to hush us up but then stayed on to sing. The woman who taught first grade math got everyone clapping. Kids pressed into the room until it was strictly SRO. Not one of them audience. The bigger the chorus grew, the faster it drew. Then our mountain of sound fell away for a measure, and not on my cue. I knew by the next upbeat what it had to be. I saw her in the doorway, even before I turned around: the school’s director.
I can’t tell what Ruth heard. Her face showed nothing. But there were her singing kids, small for the last time, and there was her brother, singing for her for the first time since we were small. Every stacked sound stayed whole in the changing chord. Then there was one more obbligato line. Who knew where the tune came from? She made it up. Improvised. The words, though, were given her:
But where will they build their nest?
Ruth’s voice went through me like death. Refusal, lament: the only answer to his holdout hope. I felt as I had when I’d heard her sing back in Philadelphia. Infinitely bereft. Her voice was lovely enough, even in ruin, to prove how the dream of music was never more than that.
One by one, I brought the lines back home. The cycles of rhythm came to rest, the pulse unwove, and the room erupted, applauding itself. Kids broke loose in all directions, a spontaneous uprising that declared the rest of the hour a national holiday. A ring formed around Jonah. “How’d you do that?” Judson grilled him. By way of answer, Jonah let loose with a bolt of Monteverdi.
My family cowered in the celebrating room. Robert drifted to his mother’s side, guilty, caught in the act. She slunk toward me, as if I, of all people, offered safety. “Robert,” Ruth told the boy, in that same weary fear with which she sent the bird and the fish, homeless, away, “that’s your uncle.”
“I know,” the boy scolded. He tried, in his excitement, to avoid the eyes of all adults. He pointed at me. “Your brother.”
Then Jonah stood beside us. “You hear that? Did you hear?” He reached to hug his sister.
Ruth stepped back. “Don’t! Too long. You can’t just…” She lost control of her voice. But she refused to cry.
Robert clenched, ready to protect her. Jonah grazed Ruth’s arm, deniable free comfort. Then he turned to clap my shoulder. “You’re a genius. The van Karajan of music. Now that’s using the stick.” He looked down at the half-sized figure at his waist. Recognition knocked him back. “Neph,” he said, exploring his own awe.
“What’s that?” Robert asked, a sucker for a puzzle. “Something like a nephew?”
Jonah nodded soberly. “A lot like a nephew.” He looked up at Ruth. “Amazing. He’s beautiful.”
“Why should that be amazing?” Cold as memory.
“That’s not. My luck is.”
Robert screwed his face up. “Your voice does funny things.”
“My standing here at all. My seeing you.”
Ruth snapped her head away. “You’re heavier,” she said. She looked back. Jonah held out his arms and looked down the length of his body. “I mean…” She traced her own throat.
“Don’t say heavier. Say richer.”
“Why are you here? Why did you come back?”
The child chorus drifted reluctantly from the room to their next assignments. My students. Jonah raced to the door to slap their hands. It bought him time. He came back, talking to Robert, gazing around the room. “Look at this! I had no idea. So this is your school!”
“My mama’s,” Robert said.
“Yours,” Ruth told her child. Tears now. But the voice was hers.
“Fantastic,” Jonah said. “I haven’t had so much fun with singing since…” He looked at Robert. “Since I was you. You heard what that sounded like? This is it. This is the next thing. People have never heard anything like this.”
Ruth’s laugh was incredulous. “Maybe not your people.”
“I’m serious. That was a sound. We could get there. Make this go. Play anywhere. I’m telling you. People need this.”
Ruth was shaking her head, her mouth pulling at her ears. “People have had this forever.”
“Not me.”
“Exactly.”
“Ruth. I’m here. I’m asking. You can’t leave me hanging.”
“You left us.”
“You have your work,” I said.
He dismissed me. “We’ve been on autopilot for almost two years. It’s pretty much over, antiquity. Heaven has played. I need something closer.”
“You?” I searched for irony, but he was grave. “You can’t quit. It’s a dying art. Who’s going to keep it alive if you quit?”
“Never fear. Western concert music is in the able hands of millions of Koreans and Japanese.”
Ruth felt it then, too. The bottomless well he’d fallen into. My sister held her son by the shoulders, armor in front of her. She reached out over Robert and cupped the back of Jonah’s neck. “Some folks die the way they were born.”
“All folks,” I said.
A smile ripped through Jonah. His sister was talking to him. Touching him. Didn’t matter what she was saying, how many barbs.
“Neph?” Jonah looked down at Robert. The future’s court of appeals. “Sing with me?”
“My mama says you’re a land unto yourself. You always make your own rules.”
“Where did you hear that?” Ruth said. “I never in my life…”
“You ever break the law?”
Jonah regarded his flesh’s half-sized image. “All the time. Me and your uncle JoJo here? We trashed them all. Major-league transgressors. We broke laws you never even heard of.”
Robert shot me a doubtful look. But his doubt floundered when he saw me remembering. “You ever go to jail?”
Jonah shook his head. “They never caught us. We were in the papers a few times, leading suspects. But they never caught up with us.” And he made a sign, swearing the boy to secrecy.