“If I said once, I’ve said a hundred times: it was a stupid hiding place,” Mr. Miller started.
“What about the chest?” She turned on him. “The chest under the bed?”
He blanched and spun on his heel and tore from the room. They could hear his heavy feet pounding up the stair to the bedroom, the creak of the bedroom door, the two swift steps across the wooden floor, and then the noise of the chest being dragged out from under the bed.
Alinor, her hands filled with faerie gold, stood as still as everyone else and listened.
“God save us, God spare us,” Mrs. Miller whispered into the silent room. “That’s all that we have in the world. We’ll be ruined if that’s bewitched too.”
They could hear him fumbling with the keys and then the creak of the lid. They could hear his sigh of relief and the chink of coins being stirred. Then they heard him slam down the lid, lock up, and come slowly down the stairs, putting the keys in his waistcoat pocket.
“Thank God it’s there,” he said, gray-faced in the doorway. “The tide-mill money is safe. It’s your savings that have gone. Jane’s dowry. How much was there?”
Even in the grip of terrible loss Mrs. Miller was not going to tell her husband how much she had put away over the years. “Pounds, I had,” Mrs. Miller said viciously. “More than forty pounds. How am I going to get it back from a witch?”
“Could be a passing thief,” Mrs. Wheatley ventured. “Someone from the yard?”
“What thief leaves handfuls of faerie gold? Nobody has come in here; nobody knows where I hide my money. It’s a witch. It’s got to be a witch. She’s magicked away my savings and left me hers in exchange. This is witch money. This is witch work.”
The room was silent. The silence thickened, curdled. Slowly, as slowly as a thought dawning, everyone turned to Alinor. Everyone looked at Alinor, who had worked for Mrs. Miller ever since she was a girl, who was known as a cunning woman with skills not of this world. Alinor, who needed gold for her daughter’s dowry, her son’s apprenticeship, who was said by her own husband to whore for faerie lords. Slowly, everyone looked at Alinor, where she stood, her face very pale, her hands filled with faerie gold.
“You saw me take the purse from the chimney on the day you went to the market for me and bought my lace collar,” Mrs. Miller said.
Alinor remembered turning her head away and seeing the reflection of Mrs. Miller fetching her purse in the shiny silver trencher.
She swallowed. “That was months ago,” she said. “In the autumn. Last year.”
“But you knew of her hiding place?” Mrs. Wheatley asked.
Alinor turned to her friend. “Yes. So did many, I should think.”
“But you knew, Alinor?”
“And you needed money,” Mrs. Stoney pointed out. “I never thought you would get the dowry together.”
“We worked,” Alys burst into speech. “Everyone saw us. We both worked. Like dogs. Here at the mill, everyone saw us working here, and we spun, and I worked the ferry. And my father gave me . . . and my uncle lent us . . .”
“I never thought it’d be enough,” Mr. Stoney contributed. “I thought you must’ve borrowed from someone.”
“No!” Alinor said proudly, and then thought she should have said yes.
“I helped Alys,” Richard interrupted, and received a savage look from his mother.
“You had no business to,” she said sharply.
“And even so,” Mr. Stoney said, “you only had your wages.”
“His inheritance?” Alinor said. Her hands were shaking, the faerie gold sparkled.
“What inheritance? He’s got no inheritance,” Mr. Stoney said.
Alys looked at her mother, her eyes huge in her pale face and silently shook her head. There was no inheritance.
“Mrs. Reekie, say it isn’t so!” Mr. Miller said to her quietly. “I’ve known you for years. Say it isn’t so.”
“Of course it isn’t so!” Alinor repeated. Even to her own ears her voice sounded weak, the denial unconvincing. She stretched her hands towards Mr. Miller’s reassuring bulk, as if to give him the faerie gold.
“No, I don’t want it!” he said, stepping back and whipping his hands behind his back. “I don’t want it in my house.”
“Let me throw it out the door then!” Alinor turned to the kitchen, and the open door to the yard. But Mrs. Miller suddenly barred the way.
“Not so fast,” she said. “You’ll have to answer for this. No dashing out. You hold that, till you prove it isn’t yours!”
“And where’s my dowry?” Jane demanded.
Alinor tried to laugh, her hands sticky with faerie coins. “Mrs. Miller, I’ve been your neighbor for all my life. My mother delivered you—”
“And everyone said she was a witch.”
“No, they didn’t.”
“She did charming. She was a cunning woman. She could find things. She could take things,” Mrs. Miller reminded her. “She could cast . . .”
“But I don’t. You know I don’t.”
“Your hands are full of faerie gold! Where’s it come from?”
“I didn’t take your money!” Alinor exclaimed. “I didn’t change it into this!”
“Lay ahold of her!” Mrs. Miller said urgently, as if Alinor’s raised voice changed everything. “She’s cursing us. And you”—she ordered her husband—“you get the other church warden or the minister. She’ll have to be charged.”
“Back to the church?”
“Are you arguing with me?” Mrs. Miller shouted at him. “A witch in our house with her hands full of faerie gold, and you’re standing there arguing with me?”
Mr. Miller cast one incredulous look at Alinor and went out of the parlor into the kitchen, and pulled on his winter cape. He threw open the door to the yard and everyone heard the sound of a horse. “Sir William,” Mr. Miller said with evident relief. “His lordship’s coming. He’s a magistrate. He can decide what’s to be done.”
Everyone in the parlor crowded around Alinor and led her through the kitchen and out into the mill yard to greet the solitary horseman. But it was not Sir William. It was James Summer.
“His lordship’s on his way.” He smiled, but then he was silenced as he saw Alinor, her cupped hands filled with coins, surrounded by frightened people. “What is this? What’s happening here?”
“It’s Mrs. Reekie, taken for a witch,” Mrs. Wheatley said, matter-of-fact, going to the horse’s head and looking up at James. “Mrs. Miller here has had her savings changed into faerie gold, and she accuses Alinor Reekie, who makes no defense.”
“What?” James demanded incredulously.
Alinor could not bring herself to face him, could not speak to him.
“It’s not true,” Alys said, pushing forwards. “Of course, it’s not true.”
“Then how are my savings turned into faerie gold, and the true coin gone?” Mrs. Miller demanded. “Who would do that, if not a witch? Who could do such a thing? And doesn’t everyone know that Alinor has always loved the faerie gold? Even when she was a girl she would find it and keep it?”
“I didn’t steal your money! Of course I knew where you had it hidden. I’ve known for months—probably everyone does. But I didn’t steal it. I wouldn’t steal from you, or anyone! I’ve been in and out of your house and your yard all my life. I go into people’s houses all the time. There’s not many houses on Sealsea Island that I’ve not attended, and I’ve never ever taken anything. I’m a licensed midwife—”
“Not got a license now,” a man remarked, making Alinor break off and look at him.
“That’s not my fault!” she said. “How can you say that against me?”
“What about Ned’s wife and baby?”
Alinor gasped. “She lost her baby. I did everything I knew . . .”