"Wait a minute, Josh. I've been thinking. There isn't but one thing for us to do. We've got to search Lazy B… every foot of it. If Bill has stolen beef, we can find it. We've been riding that range all our lives. But I don't mind saying that I'm scared… of what we may find."
The old segundo's answer showed the same fear. "I reckon this is the first time in my life that I ever hated to do a job for Wagon. Like you, I'm scared of the move, but since it's got to be done, tonight's as good a time as any!"
"Tonight," Kirby agreed, "just the two of us!"
He's thorough in everything he does, Kirby thought that night as he left the house and walked across the yard where his foreman was waiting with saddled horses. Josh had saddled the black gelding for him and another black for himself. Both saddles carried Winchesters in their scabbards, and Josh had donned a dark jacket. If anyone sees us tonight he'll have to look mighty sharp, Kirby thought as they lifted their ponies into an easy lope.
Josh was the first to speak. "The Clear's way down, Boss. I figger maybe we can ford at the place we lost them first cows and start lookin' from there."
Kirby grunted. "That's as good a place as any."
They rode the Streeter trail until they were out of sight of the house, then circled back to the river flat. They traveled by the light of a new moon, but the night was clear and they had little trouble following the river trail. Josh led the way into the ford. Kirby had to flog his black gelding with the end of the reins before he would take to the water. But once he had his feet wet he wanted to run, and Kirby had to hold him back to prevent possible disaster if he should step off into a deep hole.
There were no cattle on the Lazy B side of the river. When nearly an hour's ride deep into Lazy B graze didn't disclose a single cow, Kirby's hopes began to rise, the sick fear in his stomach to subside. He was almost gay as he said to Josh, "Looks like this is going to be a snipe hunt!"
"Mebbe. Sure hope you're right. There's one more place I'd like to see, though."
Kirby knew at once what place he meant. At the extreme edge of the old Wagon range, nature had constructed her own corral. It was a grassy meadow, bounded on three sides by rocky slopes too steep even for wild range cattle to climb. The meadow itself was big enough to hold a sizable herd, but because it was so remote from the rest of the graze, it was seldom used except late in the summer when other grass grew scarce. The only entrance was from the river side: a narrow gap in the rocky ridge. The gap was so narrow that a juniper or spruce felled across the trail made an effective gate. The top of the ridge marked Lazy B's boundary… the old Wagon Spoke limits. Beyond lay the scrubby H Bar D, owned by Hub Dawes.
As they headed their ponies into the entrance to the meadow, they reined up short, each man acting instinctively at the sound they heard… the bawling of a cow! It came again, close at hand. "That was no snipe, Josh!"
"We'd better go from here on foot, Boss." He led both ponies into a small thicket. When he returned he carried two rifles, one of which he passed wordlessly over to Kirby. Carefully, feeling their way among the loose rocks of the dark gap, they worked their way to a spot overlooking the meadow. At the sight that met their eyes, Kirby felt an anger so great that it almost made him ill. Josh gave a smothered exclamation.
Spread out as far as they could see in the dim starlight, cows were bedded down in the meadow. How many they could not tell.
Josh made a sound almost as if he were retching. Then he said, "Cover me from here. I'll slip down and see if I can read any brands." He was lost to sight almost at once. Kirby strained his eyes to see in the uncertain light and once or twice thought that he could see a dim shadow moving in and around the cattle nearest him. He knew that there couldn't have been a guard anywhere around the critters, for Josh had been gone long enough to have been spotted. Whoever had hazed the cows into the meadow had been pretty certain that they would stay put… that there was little likelihood of a chance rider stumbling into the gather.
He waited, tension building up in him almost to the breaking point, for Josh to get back. He was on the verge of starting down the slope when Josh materialized, wraith-like, from the shadows. The foreman hunkered down beside the spot where Kirby had been squatting. His voice was chill when he said, "Don't reckon we have to be so quiet. Don't believe there's a man in hearing distance… only cows."
"Could you read any burns, man? Let me know what you found down there."
"Plenty," came the cold voice. "Enough to hang Bill and his crew. There's hundreds of cows in that meadow… critters from every brand on the Streeter range. Couldn't see too well, but enough to guess that all the stuff that has been rustled lately is right here before us."
Kirby's voice was thin. "I can't seem to think, Josh. I guess I suspected that we'd find something like this, but now we know for sure…" His voice fell almost to a whisper. "What's our next move?"
"We'll ride, son. No use hanging around here." He thought for a moment. "Guess this is a hanging matter, at that."
They made no further attempt at conversation until they had crossed the ford and were back on Wagon. Finally Josh broke the long silence. "Way I see it, Kirby, Dawes has to be mixed up in this. There must be a way out of that meadow we don't know about. I can see how easy it would be to haze a few stolen critters at a time across Lazy B without anyone gettin' wise. But they couldn't drive a herd that size back across Lazy B without somebody askin' questions." The old foreman shook his head in puzzlement.
"You're saying, then, that somewhere in that meadow is a gap we don't know about… a gap that leads into Dawes' range." Kirby sounded doubtful. "I can see that would be an easy way to get rid of the herd… by driving 'em through Dawes spread and on out of the country. But, man, we've both known about that meadow for years. There isn't but one entrance…you know that."
"Has to be another, Kirby. There just has to be a hidden hole somewhere. I've been thinking. If you remember, there's a small creek cuts down from Dawes' spread and across the top of the meadow, and then on down one side to the Clear? It's dry most of the time. Only time it has much water in it is when there's a runoff after a big rain in the hills. Well, I'm betting that the rustlers have discovered a way to drive a herd out of the meadow by way of that creek bed. That has to be the answer. There just ain't no other way."
Kirby nodded in somewhat dubious agreement. "That has to be the answer. But we'll have to be sure. Men are going to hang because of what we found tonight, and we want to be sure that we have the right ones." His voice broke into something very like a sob. "Josh… I've got to hang my own brother! Maybe I won't actually pull on the rope, but when what we found tonight gets out, it'll be the same as if I'd whipped his horse out from under him and left him dangling in the air." He beat his clenched fist against the saddlehorn in an agony of despair.
Josh, too, was wracked by the horror of what had to be. "Remember, until just recent Bill was as much like a son to me as you are. But we can't shirk our duty, boy, if we want to live with ourselves. I've been thinking about tipping Bill off and givin' him a chance to ride out of the country. But I know that's the last thing old Muddy would have wanted me to do."
In mute misery they rode back to Wagon, each man weighed down by the burden of his knowledge… each knowing that not to disclose what they had discovered would make them as guilty as the men who had stolen the beef. As they unsaddled their ponies, Kirby said, "I've been thinking, Josh. We'd better tell the sheriff what we know. From there on he can handle it, and we may not even have to be in on the end."
Josh grunted in acknowledgement of Kirby's logic. But as he stalked off to the bunkhouse without another word, he knew that they would have to see the trouble through, no matter what happened.