Touching his hand, I said urgently, “Peregrine? What happened out there on the road tonight? You must tell me-who did you shoot? Was it Jonathan?”
He opened his eyes as I spoke. Then he turned his face to the wall and wouldn’t meet my gaze.
“Listen to me! Jonathan has confessed to trying to kill the two constables and you. Is it true? He may be dying, I need to know.”
There was no answer.
“You fired your pistol. While it was still in your pocket.” I reached for his greatcoat, lying across a chair’s back, and showed the blackened hole to him. “Look, here’s proof.”
“I won’t go back to the asylum,” he said finally. “I can’t face it. I’d rather be hanged.”
“Constable Mason will be all right in a day-two. He’ll be able to speak to Inspector Howard. You might as well tell me the truth. It’s the only way I can help you.”
“Mason was the first to go down. He won’t know what happened after that. I shot Jonathan,” he said, and something in the timbre of his voice rang true.
“But that doesn’t make sense. He wasn’t shot in the back while he was driving-and he couldn’t have walked that far from the motorcar, hurt as he was.”
He wouldn’t answer.
“Peregrine. I promise you, you won’t go back there-”
I could read the bleakness in his eyes as he replied, “Bess, you nearly worked a miracle. I’m grateful, truly. But I can’t walk out of here. I stood up just now and tried, and it was hopeless. Someone has taken my pistol, and so I can’t use it on myself. I’ll have to stay and face them. There’s nothing more we can do.”
I didn’t try to argue, but I was far from giving up. My father had always said I was as stubborn as a camel.
“I’ve sent for Mrs. Graham. She’ll be here shortly. I thought you’d prefer to know that.”
And then I went back to Jonathan, hoping for a little time before his mother arrived.
Jonathan was waiting for me as I opened the door to his room. When he saw the paper and pen in my hands, he said, “Hurry.”
And so I sat there, beside another Graham son, this time instead of writing a letter home, I was taking down a confession of murder.
It was brief, no details, just the stark facts. When I’d finished, he held out his hand for the pen, to sign.
I said, “Did you kill Lily Mercer, Jonathan? I know it wasn’t Peregrine. Arthur knew that too. It’s what he meant by his message to you. Surely-surely, if you’re confessing to these deaths, you will want to tell me the truth of that one as well. Peregrine doesn’t deserve to return to Barton’s. He’s suffered enough. Set him free, while you can.”
But he lay there in stony silence, his hand shaking a little as he reached a second time for the pen.
What was it about these Graham men? Stubbornly silent when they might set the record straight. First Arthur and now Jonathan and even Peregrine.
I watched him sign the confession. His signature was a scrawl, but legible enough to suffice.
“Take it to Inspector Howard. Don’t let my mother see it. It would be a cruelty.”
I agreed and was about to leave when he said, “Let it be finished.”
“It can’t be finished, if Peregrine Graham is sent back to that place. You never went there, did you? But Arthur did. And still he said nothing. Did nothing. What did he mean when he said he’d lied, for his mother’s sake? Did you lie as well? Was she the one who killed Lily Mercer, and blamed Peregrine?”
Goaded, he said, “God, no! Damn you, don’t even suggest such a thing!”
“Then why did you have to lie, for her sake?”
“I lied because the police were there and they frightened her. She’d been crying. When they asked me about the pocketknife, I told them that it was Peregrine’s, that none of us ever touched it because it was left to him by his father. I didn’t know-I was ten, I didn’t understand what it was I was doing.”
But that must have meant he knew who had had possession of that knife.
“Take the paper-go.” He was insistent, the urgency reflected in his eyes.
I looked at the man lying on the cot.
He hadn’t confessed until he’d realized Peregrine was still alive… With Peregrine dead, the police would easily have come to the conclusion that the dangerous lunatic had run amok. They might still feel that way.
And Peregrine was claiming he’d shot Jonathan-but not the policemen. If he wanted to hang, why not admit to three people? Then where was the need for Jonathan to take the blame?
It was dark out there in the field. When he’d run off the road, why hadn’t Jonathan left the motorcar’s headlamps burning?
So that the other occupants of the motorcar couldn’t see what he’d seen-that someone else had been there?
And the Graham dogcart was standing in the yard of The Bells. It had been used tonight.
I said, “This confession is a lie. Who did you meet on the road tonight?”
He shut his eyes, not answering me.
“I saw him running away-I thought at first it was Peregrine. But Peregrine was already down, wasn’t he? He fired at someone, and missed. While you were struggling for control of your own revolver. That’s why I thought I’d only heard four shots. It wasn’t Peregrine who wounded you, it was Timothy, wasn’t it? And you’re still protecting him! How many people must he kill before he’s stopped?”
“My brother-he’s my brother.”
“So is Peregrine, and you left him to the horrors of an asylum.”
I took a deep breath, feeling a wave of exhaustion sweep over me. There was only one other thing I wanted to know. But Jonathan was having difficulty breathing and I moved his pillows to make him more comfortable.
Dr. Philips was at the door, saying, “The ambulance is on its way.”
I turned to Jonathan. “Will you at least tell me what Arthur had done that distressed him so? I brought his message-”
Someone spoke from just behind Dr. Philips. It was Mrs. Graham, her face starkly pale, her gaze on Jonathan. “He didn’t confide in you after all. I was so sure he had. The police asked him if Peregrine had ever been violent before. And Arthur answered that we were all afraid of him. Arthur had been standing outside the parlor where the police were questioning me, he knew what had been said. He knew I’d claimed that I’d found that same knife deep in my pillow one night. It was a large pocketknife, a man’s. The police were appalled. I knew they would be. Arthur saw that I was close to breaking down, and he lied to make them leave me alone.”
Two boys, barely understanding what was happening around them, telling lies because they were afraid, confused, and trying to please the adults who were interrogating them. And with their words, damning their half brother to a lifetime in a madhouse. But they’d never been taught to think of him as their brother, had they? Mrs. Graham had purposely kept them apart.
“What did Timothy tell the police?”
She took a deep breath. “He told the police that Peregrine had once threatened to carve him like a Christmas goose with that same knife.”
I wanted to bury my face in my hands and cry. On the lies of these three children, their mother had been able to protect her own son and keep him safe all these years, even knowing him for what he was. And no one had given a thought to Peregrine. He was the outcast, he was the eldest, and this woman had convinced herself that in the end his life would not have amounted to much anyway.
She couldn’t have loved Robert that much. But she had loved Timothy. And Timothy was only nine at the time.
“Why would Timothy wish to kill Lily?”
“Apparently that night she saw his foot after his bath. Jonathan was there later when she told Timothy-a child, mind you!-that it was ugly and hairy and useless. He never showed that foot to anyone. She told him it was the devil’s club and he was the devil’s spawn. When I heard that, I felt nothing for her, I owed her nothing.” Her voice was harsh, cold.