"Can you lose weight?" I asked, because at least it was a conversation with somebody who wasn't trying to get wafted up into heaven or deeper into hell. And also it was kind of funny.
"You can look thinner," said the fat guy, "if you start to think of yourself as thin."
"So why can't you think of yourself as good, and get on up into heaven?"
He shook his head. "Those street preachers, they aren't thinking of themselves as good. They're thinking of themselves as righteous. Saved. Chosen."
"Better than everybody else."
"Bingo. Ditto with the bad dudes and the tough girls. They're needy, all of them, and needy doesn't get you off the street. Needy is what gets you on the street."
"If you've got it all figured out," says I, "what are you still doing here?"
"I'm conflicted," he said. "A common problem. Whenever I start going one direction, I do something to send me back the other." He grinned. "While you, you're talented."
Talented? "I'm not the one reading minds here. I mean, you've been answering stuff I didn't say."
"Yeah, I've got good hearing. I don't have to wait for you to speak. Because, you know, it's not like we actually have voices. We just sort of wish our thoughts to be heard, and then people close by can hear them. But your thoughts are actually just as loud, so to speak. So yeah, I can hear stuff. But you, you can see things."
I looked around. "No more than anybody else."
"Nope, nope, not so. I watched you. Crossing the street. You waited for the light."
"I did not. The lights don't change."
"And you dodged the pedestrians."
"There are no pedestrians."
"Nevertheless."
"I don't see them, so how can I dodge them?"
"Oh, you philosopher, you."
"What possible difference could it make to you?"
"I want to see how useful you are. What you can do."
"This is a job interview?"
"I've got an opening for an elf."
I looked him over, this time more carefully. No pipe clenched between his teeth, but his stomach was rather like a bowlful of jelly. "Am I supposed to laugh when I see you in spite of myself?"
"Clement Moore didn't actually see me," he said. "I'd long since stopped doing personal appearances by then. But you see, it doesn't make much difference. I've got this image in my face every Christmas -- no, every Halloween and two months after -- and it's all I can do to keep from wearing the red suit all year long. I used to be thin, when the Dutch were in charge of the image."
"What are you doing in hell? Aren't you supposed to be Saint Nicholas?"
"I'm not in hell. Any more than you are."
"Here's a clue, Nick. This ain't heaven."
"We're hovering, my friend. Or maybe we're volleying, like the shuttlecock in badminton, back and forth, almost one thing, almost another."
"Me, I'm just walking the streets."
"Dodging the pedestrians."
"I'm not a toymaker."
"Fine with me. That toymaking, that's just part of the myth. Hasn't anybody caught on that I'm dead? They don't issue us hammers and saws and set us to work making wooden toys. There's precious few of us can even see the living, and those that can move things in the material world, those are even more rare."
"So how do you come up with all those toys for good girls and boys?"
"When we need toys, which isn't as often as you think, we steal them."
"Ah," I said. "Now I'm beginning to get why you aren't in heaven. You aren't Santa Claus. You're Robin Hood."
"Mostly we break toys," said Santa. "Or hide them. It's not like we can move anything very far. And nowadays it's a cash economy. Come to think of it, it was back when I was alive, too. They used to draw pictures of me with bags of money, because that's what I did, my famous good deed, I paid a ransom in coin, saved some kids. Money's what we mostly use now, too. And because it's paper, it's even easier. Lighter. Even my less talented elves can move it."
I couldn't help it. He was so serious. I laughed. "Man, you had me going there. Santa Claus, stealing toys, breaking them, hiding them, dealing in cash. You got your elves out picking pockets?"
He didn't look amused. "Yes," he said. "I fail to see the humor."
"You're not putting me on?"
"I want to see if you can move things. In the material world."
"I told you, I can't even see the people, let alone pick their pockets, and even if I could, I've never been a thief." At once my conscience twinged. "At least, not deliberately. Not systematically."
"You got a better job offer?"
"I want a shot at heaven," I said. "As long as I'm not completely in hell, why not?"
"Me too," said Santa. "Some years I've been so close."
"What about getting into the devil's workshop? Been close to that, too?"
He shrugged. "As a novelty act, they've invited me now and then. But not to stay. Strictly in the back door, you know."
"Why should I do this? I mean, you've been at this for what, fifteen hundred years? And you're still here."
"Got any better plans? It's not like you're running out of time."
"Santa, excuse me for saying this, but as far as I can tell, you're as looney as a one-legged duck."
He shook his head. "My friend, nobody's crazy here. We might be wrong about a lot of stuff, but we can't lie and we aren't crazy. Still, like I said, no hurry. Look me up if you decide Santa's gang of elves sounds more interesting than ... whatever it is you're doing."
"How would I find you?"
He rolled his eyes. "Just ask. In case you didn't know it, I'm famous. People keep track of where I am."
"I was afraid I'd have to go to the north pole or something."
He shook his head, turned his back, and walked away.
He was right. I could see living people. And it wasn't a matter of slowing down or speeding up, either. It was more like you had to pay attention to something else, sort of look away and then be aware of what's going on at the edges of things. Only that's the strange thing -- when you're dead, there are no edges. You have the habit, from all those years of binocular vision, of seeing only this window in front of you, with out-of-focus glimpses to the sides, and most dead people never get past that. But the fact is, when you're dead you don't have those limitations. You can see ... well, you remember how people used to say that teachers seemed to have eyes in the back of their heads? Or it's like, you could feel someone's gaze on you, even though they were behind you? Well, that's how it is when you're dead, once you get the hang of it. You're aware in every direction. It's not really vision. It's just knowledge, but your mind kind of makes sense of it like vision. I wasn't consciously seeing those moving cars or pedestrians, so I didn't "know" they were there. But I was aware of them, aware of the people in the cars, aware of the people on the street, and some old reflex made me dodge them, weave among them without knowing it.
Thanks to the tip from Nick -- I hate calling him Santa Claus because that name's too loaded down with cultural freight, I just have to laugh whenever I think of saying, "Hi, Santa!" -- I got pretty good at seeing mortals. Got to be a habit, really, knowing where they were, knowing what they were doing. I found my range was pretty good, too, because this awareness thing, it isn't blocked by mere walls, I know who's coming around the corner before they actually come into my field of view. And I'm not a genius, either, I can imagine there's those that can see for miles, right through hills and cities and whatever else is in the way. Maybe see forever, if they've got the mind to sort through all the stuff you'd see in between.
And it wasn't just awareness. I could move stuff.
The thing is, touching the material world, changing it, that doesn't come the way awareness did -- it isn't just automatically happening, so you only have to notice it. Ordinarily, when you're dead you simply don't affect the material world in any way. You don't sink through the earth or walk through walls, but only because you still have the respect for those surfaces you learned when you were alive. You can go through them, just as you can sink down into the earth, though that's extraordinarily boring, since nothing much is going on once you get past the earthworm and gopher level.